Inquiry

Why is it important to bring the Integral Approach to education?

How do you envision this happening? What benefits could an Integral approach bring to the education system? What can you do to help this effort?

Please Log in to Vote.

3 out of 3 members found this useful.

yeah, I have seen this myself...but then again...

So I am a professor.  And I have been a professor at two different universities - both of which have a very different view of what higher education (at the graduate school level) looks like.  Let me explain:

The first university (which remain nameless...although some of you may be able to identify it) claimed to have an Integrative Emphasis in the PsyD clinical psychology program.  I graduated from here and attended because of the emphasis they claimed to have.  I noticed first as a student, the lack of support for the emphasis coupled with a quite desire to keep the whispers and gossip about integrative just slightly under the radar so that students were aware something was amiss, but could not identify what.  It didn't help that the school refused to hire a psychologist to head the emphasis and padded the other emphasis areas with very accomplished educators and clinicians.  As a professor there, I found the depth of their admonishment.  Almost a threatening of their existing operating system.  God forbid we open up a conversation about how psychoanalytic theory or cognitive behavioral theory can be examined using a different lens...So, if we could nto even examine the integral nature of psychology, we certainly were not operating in an integral way...therefore, discussion of the topics other that psychology in the integral theory were a long shot - and simply ignored.  

Where I am now is at National University.  What a difference!!  The faculty there are naturally more integral in nature (although some do not know the theory - or focus,etc).  To be in a climate where PhD's and PsyD's respect each other's work and are aware and open to how they can work for the better of both quantitative and qualitative examinations, to be actively engaged in creating an education approach that addresses the four quadrants openly, lead by a chair whose integrative mindedness is recognized, and is aware of how such an approach will create more integrally informed future therapists has created a freedom in me that has allowed for my own professional and personal development to flourish!  How can we call it education without exposure to the integral nature of life itself.

Don't get me wrong.  I think that as one specializes in an area, that area will be focused on maybe a quadrant or two, which is necessary to create expertise.  So there is room for that as well.  But it must start with a wide net and then a focus versus a focus that eventually leads to a wider net...ahh..just some thoughts.

Namaste -

 Christina Zampitella, Psy.D.

 

Please Log in to Vote.

4 out of 4 members found this useful.

view from the ground up

--I am currently a sophomore at the University of Wyoming. I became acquainted with Integral theory early in my freshman year. I discovered Integral Naked and Integral Life online and have learned most about the Integral Operating System from online resources.

Nearly every facet of the Integral approach has helped me in the past year. The developmental lines and stages have shed light on my personal relationships as well as others' motivations. The states have helped me understand meditation and dreaming. It is the quadrants that have helped me the most in class and day to day homework.

In my education thus-far i have been exposed to many different theories. I have found all of them to be partial from an Integral perspective. They tend to be centered around one or two quadrants while ignoring/demeaning the others.The truth probably lies in a careful concept amalgamation.

I imagine myself as a professor and teaching Integral Theory during the first week of class. It is the best tool i have found for understanding the theories and perspectives of others.

I have mentioned the Integral Approach to friends and professors. I feel like it is a secret that can only be revealed at the right moment in someone's development for it to be accepted. This is the largest obstacle i have found. My closest friends are very interested but I haven't met any professors I feel would give it a go.

I extend my sincerest gratitude to KW and all the beautiful members, operators, and contributors of Integral Naked and Integral Life. The privilege of vision comes with the responsibility of action.

Shane-o

Please Log in to Vote.

0 out of 0 members found this useful.

the Importants of Intregal Education

I am a certified secondary education social science teacher for the state of Georgia. In teacher training we study Piaget's developmental model and Gardner's lines of development but they are never connected. One of the most useful theories that we learn is Vygotsky's zones of development and scaffolding. Instinctually I saw these ideas as being complimentary to each other but when I talked to my friends in graduate school they told me how Vygotsky's and Piaget's ideas are opposed to each other and that I would have to choose sides. Before I came across Wilber's work I knew this was wrong but I didn't have the framework for expressing why. Also I think the AQAL framework will make understanding history, geography, political science, and economics so much easier by providing a structure and a place to arrange and store complex ideas and trends. I know it has made every thing so much clearer in my own thinking. I cannot imagine teaching without it. That would be like teaching biology without evolution or chemistry without the periodic table. -- R.S.Calvert

Please Log in to Vote.

1 out of 1 members found this useful.

In the trenches...

I'm a middle school English teacher, and I've been very interested in applying the integral approach to education.  As far as theory goes, there is already a lot of stuff there, ready to be applied, but most people are not aware of a way to synthesize all the material.  This is where AQAL is definitely useful.

I myself am interested in integral pedagogy, where the entire process from lesson plan design to instructional delivery is integrally informed.  Not just thinking about differentiated instruction (D.I.) and multiple intelligences (M.I.), but D.I. and M.I. from an integral perspective.  

I was at a professional development workshop last week, and it dealt with the instruction of English Language Learners (ELL's), and it was said that the core skills we needed to focus on were reading, writing, speaking, and listening; and at that moment, the idea popped into my head- how to teach children to read, write, speak, and listen in an integral way.  Definitely a daunting, yet interesting inquiry...

Please Log in to Vote.

0 out of 0 members found this useful.

Integral discipline

Normal 0 0 1 210 1199 9 2 1472 11.1539 0 0 0

 I trained as an art teacher a couple of years ago and have found the integral model very useful, and there are two thoughts I have on how integral education might be applied:

Firstly is within art education. Getting students aged 11 to 18 to write with depth about pieces of artwork can be a difficult task, even with gifted students. I have found most art departments use Rod Taylor's model of 'content, form, process and mood', with a bit of 'who did it?' and 'what do you think?' thrown in for good measure. I am currently developing an approach that uses the AQAL model to guide students through all the quadrants so they can touch base with all of reality and create a rich context of understanding.

I think some subject specific integral approaches would be really interesting. I have a friend who uses the integral model regularly when teaching religious education and is getting some great results.

Secondly is discipline. Here in England dealing with students who misbehave and disrupt lessons varies greatly from school to school and discipline is something I have found frustrating in my last school, as it didn't really exist within the whole school structure. I thing educating the educators with the integral model could yield great results in this area. Talking to a red student in the right way and then presenting in green to the whole class and knowing how and what your doing could push teaching along way.

 

My two thoughts

 

Namaste