Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Andrew Cohen
So after the first Parliament of World Religions he realized that true "sincerity of heart" did in fact exist outside of his own chest. It was a beautiful thing. Even Ken couldn't resist adding the verbal underscore (Two Drives of Evolution).
This old Integral Naked stuff is great. Sho' beats a sitcom.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- show all sub-comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Say Something Nice
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Brenden in response to [Comment Deleted]I love Ken's sigh at the end...
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
I love this video
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Scott Marshall in response to [Comment Deleted]Something cool is going on here in this video. I admire the courage of the woman who is clearly a mess about all this. Certainly I can relate to what she appears to be going through.
On a side note, something about Andrew Cohen reminds me of Adrian Monk. Or maybe its Adrian Monk who reminds me of Cohen. Oh brother...
!
~S
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
what is the significance of these exchanges
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Ambo Suno in response to [Comment Deleted]What is the significance of these exchanges for you, Maria. I'm wondering also what Brendan meant above. So little is said about what you each actually feel and think and I'm trying to follow. It's like that there's a subtext that I haven't read. I'm interested and this video is rich for possible reaction and response. Would you be willing to say more? Thanks
ambo
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
6 out of 6 members found this useful.
Incredible piece of video...
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Durwin Foster in response to [Comment Deleted]That is really an incredible clip, because it highlights so clearly how different are the approaches to working with others of Ken and Andrew. Ken clearly has a far greater understanding of psychological processes than does Cohen; he recognizes that this speaker is likely suffering from a fulcrum 2 lesion, and he knows that someone who has been wounded at a fundamental level like this is not going to be able to hear a "tough love" message like what Cohen is delivering. This is truly a case akin to what Jack Engler spoke about: "you need to have a self before you can let go of it". Thus, Ken affirms her reality, while also pointing out to her that this this reality is arising within spacious awareness.
As a psychotherapist, which is what I am, I would never suggest to a depressed person that they "kill themselves".
I admire Cohen for what has clearly been his ability to lift himself up by his bootstraps. This is autobiographical for him, and his achievements speak to his ability to do this. But in the context of assisting this woman, the approach he used for himself is not likely to work!
I would be very interested to hear about what she did with this information from the two teachers. What next steps she took, and so forth. Does anyone know more of the story?
Durwin
--
durwinfoster@gmail.com
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
The Wisdom of the Valley
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Brenden in response to Incredible piece of video...I have always envied those who have an experience of Big Mind and immediately swear off "messing around with objects" (as Ken likes to say) for the rest of their lives all at once!!! It seems like some of the early Advaita teachers like Andrew or Ganga-Ji have drawn the line of Satsang so close to Ultimate side of the street, that the true sincere desire of the ego for the Transcendent gets "looked down upon" from the view of the Transcendent herself. Not to mention the very real suffering that goes with this sincere wish or Calling. To me this woman, God bless her, is expressing some frustration that isn't entirely clear. But I'm not prepared to say it isn't appropriate as it is. Maybe the assumption is that negative human experiences like the one she describes are less profound than the other end swing of the pedulum. I would have like to see one of them push her even further in to where she was, and see if there wasn't a diamond in the middle of that haystack. (I love that special tantric twist of real deep authentic personal experience - where garbage becomes gold in the alchemy of awareness.) Helplessness can become bliss if it leads to real letting go, right? I seem to remember Alan Watts saying something about the wisdom of the valley...
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
I agree with Durwin
Posted October 8th, 2009 by Samuel Tornqvist in response to Incredible piece of video...You said it very well Durwin. Thanks for this post.
I completely agree with your comments on Wilber and Cohen.
It is very hard to give away toys you have not fully played with. My own experience is that you won't give up any fixation until you can see it and accept it. If you are not heard, the fixation stays hidden - shadow. Not letting oneself be is only fueling super-ego no matter how wise the idea is.
Ken knows this and it shows. I understand Cohen's wisdom and perspective but this time he clearly puts his foot in it. It is embarrasing. Does he not get levels? His talk is above her and will just keep her where she is with a more "spiritual" super-ego, chrashing down harder on herself.
Samuel Törnqvist
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 24th, 2009 by admin in response to [Comment Deleted]Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 24th, 2009 by admin in response to [Comment Deleted]Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Who are you referring to here?
Posted August 25th, 2009 by Durwin Foster in response to [Comment Deleted]Hi Ren:
I do not understand who you are referencing here...who is playing "vote against" and saying nothing?
--
durwinfoster@gmail.com
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 25th, 2009 by admin in response to Who are you referring to here?Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Sincerity is key
Posted August 26th, 2009 by Durwin Foster in response to [Comment Deleted]Thanks for clarifying. Sincerity is key, as I think you mean when you say "shouldn't we all want to be serious at some point?" Absolutely!
Yours,
Durwin
--
durwinfoster@gmail.com
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
3 out of 3 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 25th, 2009 by admin in response to [Comment Deleted]Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Cohen As Therapist
Posted August 26th, 2009 by Brenden in response to [Comment Deleted]I met Andrew once in Boston, and he told me that from his perspective suicide was always an expression of aggression. (He also told me that I should stop thinking of spirituality as a hobby. True enough.) But as a therapist I think he was mistaken about suicide. He also said psychotherapists were doing something fundamentally different from what he was doing. I have spent a lot of time thinking about therapy and what it is. And I'm pretty sure that from the biggest perspective, it's the same thing.
I've also spent time thinking about what it must be like for Andrew to deal with people who have had glimpses of what he has seen, but don't take it seriously enough to change forever. It must be frustrating. Now he thinks 51% is enough. That's a loss of 49 points!
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 26th, 2009 by admin in response to Cohen As TherapistPlease Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
last words
Posted August 27th, 2009 by steven martini in response to [Comment Deleted]Hey Dora-
A friend literally just posted a video of kurt cobain on my facebook wall - after watching I came here and read your thread.
I sometimes wonder, if it were me, and I was there, ready to go, would my final state be depression with a quick burst of aggressive energy to pull the trigger, or totally calm and serenely numb? What would I write as my last words?
Your family in laws take on suicide is sobering. When I summon the romanticism I used to have of volition in the final act - aspects of which still linger in my fragmented shadow - right next to how bad my parents would feel - I would only hope they would eventually have to see it the way you are saying it.
Now whenever I get that feeling of wanting to die - i play around with it to get closer to the part of the ego who sits right there between pondering to be or not to be. And then the subject object flippage occurs and I get a shot of bliss from the non-dual causal trance state - where there's no birth or death or volition or fate - and I'm okay again.
Even though he kind of creeps me out, I do think Andrew's approach in this video might work on someone like myself. And I love the way Ken tempers it with his heart. This is a great scene. I agree it's better than a sit-com or drama.
Regarding Cobain, I've always thought it was oddly apropos that the post modern pop culture moniker of Nirvana blew his mind out of his head. I imagine the buddha is still laughing.
For now my last words would be: no words apply.
--
∞ 1 2 3 4 3 2 1 ∞
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 27th, 2009 by admin in response to last wordsPlease Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Great Comments
Posted August 27th, 2009 by Brenden in response to [Comment Deleted]Thanks for your post (and your honesty!) I have some sympathy for what you are saying here. When I heard Andrew's reaction to the Parliament of World Religions http://in.integralinstitute.org/talk.aspx?id=303 I thought maybe he was growing beyond this sense of isolation and exceptionalism. It's very clear in this dialogue what a shock it is for him to discover others who are as committed as himself to growth and evolution. I thought real love might sneak in the cracks.
Early in my own journey-beyond Andrew was one of the first Americans who was saying things that matched my experiences and helped me to make sense of them. I have all the first copies of What Is Enlightenment in a box - even before the fancy covers. His travels and conversations with other spiritual teachers really helped me understand my own process. This was a big deal for me, and the struggle to understand how to contextualize awakening in our century and culture is still a work in progress for me. I will always be in his debt for his help in this. And I will always respect his passion in pushing the boundaries.
However just like you, when I first saw this video it stuck in my craw for a long time. I guess the thing that got me about his suicide comment is his laugh afterwords. Just seems weird and unfunny. He speaks so clearly (esp in his early days) about enlightenment. I love (and try to live by) the Five Fundamental Tenents. And yet I can't shake this sense that the depth of silence and sweet liquid love of stillness and peace that comes from true surrender and Humility in the face of the Mystery is somehow missing from his approach. In some ways it takes us back to the whole state-stages dilemma. How can someone access Pure Witnessing without becoming the sweet love of the Heart? And yes, Ken's spontaneous compassionate course correction in the video is nice to see...
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Times of Trouble
Posted August 29th, 2009 by Brenden in response to [Comment Deleted]"I have been as that girl was describing and I saw her predicament as a crisis, her mind was intuiting something that her reasoning could not understand and my advice to her would have been to just sit in the silence and let the silence explain it all to her."
So I've been thinking about it for a few days. And I think you've said something important here. It seems like Andrew's bootstrap style might risk taking one further out of the actual Truth of the moment - rather than through the fire (no matter what it is) to the cool water on the Otherside. Deep, let-it-be, respect for what is seems to be the only way through to rest and Witnessing. No matter which end the pedulum is swinging.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Love and Happiness
Posted September 15th, 2009 by Brenden in response to [Comment Deleted]So I guess I wanted him to say something about the always already bliss and joy Deep Space untouched Conscious ground underlying whatever is all the time. Seeing through the mist and having a chuckle (even about feeling like not chuckling). Sometimes on a cloudy day, there appears to be no sun at all. But this doesn't mean the sun stopped shining. And I'm not sure the ego can bootstrap itself to peace on a rainy day no matter how determined the effort. We might be able to clear some clouds, but we can't make the sun send light.
This person has a lot of heart. That's clear if nothing else. Love and joy travel together. So something in her is already pointed in the right direction! And with a little resonance and marination I wonder if we might not have seen some grins through the rain. And just as importantly, a deeper openning of her own empowerment as that energy became fully integrated...(self-liberating suchness smelling like a rose with no name).
"The first movement of emptiness is love. That's also the first calling. It leads to the whole universe, the creativity of this existence, and the birthing of it. All arises out of this indescribable sense of love and beauty. It's the first expression of nothingness. In that sense, love is often a portal or doorway into the truest deepest state..." -Adya
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cn5DLp8y3tg&feature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jfWPDGWP568
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
I don't follow
Posted August 24th, 2009 by Ambo SunoHi Brenden - I don't understand you references. I suspect some irony here but I'm not sure. You do catch my curious attention. Would you be willing to state clearly what you are saying, thinking and feeling about Andrew Cohen, since I am interested in the topic. Thanks,
ambo
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse








.jpg)
Please Log in to Vote.
4 out of 5 members found this useful.
[Comment Deleted]
Posted August 24th, 2009 by admin