Please Log in to Vote.
5 out of 5 members found this useful.
Holosync: Does anyone know if Ken Wilber and/or I-I still endorses Holosync?
I am interested in this technology and have found both pro and con discussions on various internet sites. I-I sites have little, as far as I can tell.
I have tried Holosync's demo CD and it seems intriguing. But before investing the time and money on their program, I'd like to hear from a trusted source, not just random strangers on the internet. I have listened to the Integral Naked interview between Ken Wilber and Bill Harris, but I believe that was done some time ago and, if I'm not mistaken, Ken was still learning about it. Ken was excited about the technology and was interested in collaborating with Bill to research the program.
So, does anyone know if Ken and/or the folks at Integral Institute are still endorsing Bill Harris and Holosync? Have they compared and contrasted it with the other binaural entrainment programs out there?
Thanks!
- Please Login to Add Comments
- show all sub-comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
Integral Holosync discussions
Posted October 19th, 2008 by aeryckI purchased the first level and have found it a great state-inducing tool. Haven't used it for a while, but I don't have anything bad to say about the technology. (As has been mentioned quite often in Integral circles, the marketing is a whole other story.)
Anyway, this should keep you busy for a while:
http://multiplex.integralinstitute.org/Public/cs/forums/thread/25141.aspx
http://multiplex.integralinstitute.org/Public/cs/search/SearchResults.aspx?q=holosync
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Response: But what about Ken Wilber?
Posted October 19th, 2008 by Martin SchoenThank you all for your quick responses!
I spent some time with the links and the threads. However, I'm still not really convinced either way. Yes, I suppose I should just try it because, as they say, Holosync has a money back guarantee for 1 year, right?! But not quite ready yet.
Thanks so much to Jim O'Neil for the "masteringthepowerofnow.com" link and the interviews. Unfortunately, only one is available (Genpo Roshi) and Ken Wilber's won't be available for a while. I'll listen to Genpo's interview with Bill Harris soon, but my question still stands in case anyone else is reading this who might know of a post somewhere that includes a recent opinion from Ken Wilber on Holosync or any of the other teachers at I-I who have tried Holosync.
A lot to ask, I suppose, but what the heck...
Thanks!
Martin Schoen
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Thanks Wayne!
Posted October 20th, 2008 by Martin SchoenThank you, yes, those links were helpful!
I listened to Bill Harris' interview with Genpo Roshi today and Genpo did mention he uses and enjoys Holosync. Just a passing comment, really, but considering the source, I was heartened to hear it. So I believe I'll give it a whirl, but still looking forward to the rest of his "mastering the power of now" interviews. (I've enjoyed many of Eckhart Tolle's recordings, but I agree with Bill that Eckhart is short on method and pratical recommendations.)
Thanks all!
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Research
Posted October 21st, 2008 by Robb SmithMartin - I spoke with Bill Harris in reply to this thread and he suggested anyone interested go to the
research sectionof the Holosync site. I also found
this linkwhich offers a competing alternative to H/S at a lower cost for those on a budget.
Robb Smith
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Thanks, Robb!
Posted October 21st, 2008 by Martin SchoenThanks so much for the information! I checked out the web site and the Insight/Focus product. It is curious, to say the least, that they claim to produce the effects that Holosync offers for only $35 to $50 and with only one CD or one "level." Obviously, that's quite attractive compared to what I understand is somewhere in the ballpark of $1000 for the complete Holosync program!
Robb, are you able to ask Bill Harris about this competition and their claim to do what Holosync does so much quicker and cheaper? This is all getting rather confusing--I'm prone to trust Harris and Centerpointe as the gold standard given the endorsements by Wilber et al., but I'm a cheapskate by nature, so I like to shop around!
Thanks!
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Lifeflow?
Posted October 22nd, 2008 by dhsmusicI was considering Holosync for a while, however, I was put off by the high cost, and also what felt like a pushy & patronizing sales rap.
I did some research and discovered Lifeflow: www.project-meditation.org/lifeflow.html. It claims to be more advanced than Holosync, and seems highly recommended by many folks. Plus it's much less expensive.
I haven't tried Holosync, other than the demo CD, so I can't really speak personally about how it compares to Lifeflow. Does anyone have any experience with this?
Thanks, D
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
My experience with Holosync
Posted October 22nd, 2008 by trwileyI have been using Holosync for over a year and am on the second level. I do like it, although it is expensive. However, I have found all the support material that comes with it to be very valuable. Bill Harris has a great way of explaining things and discusses everything from stages of development to open systems theory. His blogs are quite educational as well. I feel that I have learned a lot from him.
But I might check out the Insight CD or Lifeflow due to the cheaper cost and maybe so I don't have to do an hour each time.
Ken Wilber in one interview plugged Holosync but suggests that you still should do traditional meditation. I believe also that there is value to doing both, so I have been doing holosync and trying to traditional meditation as well.
Bill Harris is always selling a product of his or someone else, but I guess I just don't let it bother me.
Troy
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
experience with Holosync
Posted October 23rd, 2008 by Alison HammondI have been using Holosync fairly regularly for 3-4 years. I enjoy using it, it helps me make the space and time to sit for an hour and I have definitely changed (slowly) over the last few years. However, I don't really know how much of the change is due only to Holosync. I think it has helped me manage stress and together with personal therapy I think it has helped me to develop different perspectives, and become a lot less anxious and more willing to try new things.
I have never had any of the "amazing experiences" described in the marketing blurb. I sometimes get odd bodily sensations and a sense of 'coming back' to awareness but not knowing where I've been (but I know wasn't asleep) but mostly my experience over the years has been very unremarkable! I currently feel I've reached a bit of a plateau and my development has stalled. This might be just where I am right now rather than a failure of Holosync. It is expensive and I always buy my next level in one of the sales!
I hope this is helpful.
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
holosync vs self-guided meditation
Posted October 27th, 2008 by Meg SalterI am a long term meditator, long term fan of Wilber and I-I, have bought the first level of Holosync and used it for a month or so. I do recall Ken saying somewhere/sometime on the site that the brain changers of Holosync users vs the brain changes of meditators are not as rich or multi- connected. So, if you are 'just not the kind of person who is going to meditate', then by all means use Holosync (my recollection of a KW quote). I believe there is some brain research out there that indicates the deepest structural changes occur when there is significant intentionality. Personally, I find the Holosync experience initeresting, and there is definitely something going on. Meditation is a much richer, more self-directed experience, however.
I do find Bill Harris's blog postings a remarkably good, and simple explanation of much of the Integral theory. Kind of like Integral for dummies - at its best. And all the marketing can get annoying - but hay- he's got to make a living too.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
Holosync perspectives
Posted November 8th, 2008 by sham609I've been using Holosync daily for the last 5 years(I'm near the end of the Purification level), and will share my experience and thoughts. When I first started using Holosync I had been meditating for about a year. My initial experiences with Holosync was that it induced deep (subtle) states of consciousness much more rapidly than standard meditation techniques. Over time, I have found that even deeper (? causal) states arise with regularity, and over the years I've seen these states change the way I behave and react in the gross state of daily life.
I would say that with consistent, patient use of Holosync the cost of the product has been worth it. I still think one should "supplement" Holosync with standard meditation techniques, but given how busy most of us are Holosync alone is certainly better than no meditation.
I think the "science" behind Holosync is fairly sound (though in its infancy), and the neurologic impact of long term Holosync use is probably similiar to long term meditation (though realize that different meditation techniques seem to cause different neurologic effects). I'm very interested in seeing so "simul-tracking" type research on Holosync, evaluating both the upper-right quadrant effects, but also the upper-left effects.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Not for me
Posted November 8th, 2008 by Helen DavisI suffer from atypical chronic depression, and I found that Holosync made it worse. After a lot of research I discovered that depressives usually have brainwaves that are too slow anyway. I was advised to give Neuroprogrammer a go, which I did, and have had tremendous results with a programme that actually 'speeds up' the brainwaves in my left hemisphere while simulataneously slowing them down on the right. It's a considerably cheaper than Holosync as well, and you don't get all that advertising spam that Bill sends out at least once a week.
Helen
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
My Two Cents on Holosync.
Posted January 10th, 2009 by BryanI've been using holosync for about a year and I'm still on level one. I enjoy listening to it which leads me to meditate more frequently. I use it almost every day. Unfortunately, I have trouble getting myself to devote an hour to it at a time. So, frequently I just listen to "the dive" which is the first 30 mintues rather than the entire hour. I haven't noticed any huge breakthroughs, but I enjoy it and feel that it's probably a healthy thing to do. Eventually, I plan to move on to the other levels. By the way, I hardly ever hear anything from Bill Harris anymore. So, the ton of advertising/supporting e-mails don't go on forever. In summary, I give holosync a "thumbs up".
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
2 out of 2 members found this useful.
Update
Posted January 11th, 2009 by Martin SchoenNice to see people are still responding!
After 3 months, I am really impressed with Holosync and I plan on moving on to the next level in a month or so. I've noticed positive changes such as less stress and more graceful responses during stress. Sometimes I ask myself: "I wonder why I didn't feel any anxiety in that situation?"
It seems that the impact of the meditation increases when I also practice mindfulness meditation (i.e., witnessing) during the recording instead of just daydreaming etc. Waves of endorphins seem to be released when I do that, i.e., letting go of control or effort seems to increase the intensity of what the recording is doing. Toward the end of the hour, it seems I have short periods of "no thinking" and I wonder if it's what Wilber means by "causal awareness" as in deep sleep periods. The recording is also an easy way to induce sleep when wired up--just listen to "The Dive" for 10 or 15 minutes and it's nap time!
Of course, one of the main things about the Holosync program is that it got me to develop the habit of meditating for an hour everyday!
Peace.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Update 2
Posted March 29th, 2010 by Martin SchoenO.K., it's been about 1 1/2 years of consistent, daily meditation practice with Holosync and I'm now using Awakening Level 3.
I must say I'm very, very glad I started using it. I will repeat what I said before: by practicing mindfulness meditation (attending to the breath when the mind wanders, trying to watch the process of thinking, "witnessing" etc.) while using Holosync makes the program more powerful. I'm experiencing many of the results that Centerpointe describe. Apart from Holosync sessions, I find that, anytime I stop and meditate during the day and/or use self-hypnosis, I quickly "drop down" into a meditative or trance state--more quickly than I had been before Holosync. There are other positive psychological, developmental effects I won't go into here. In short, I recommend it highly and suggest that beginners complete Awakening Level 1 (minimum 4 months) before you make up your mind about the program--6 to 9 months would be better.
I just wish Bill Harris would tone down the marketing stuff. Oh, well....
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Update 3
Posted May 14th, 2010 by Martin SchoenIf anyone stumbling onto this thread has not already seen this presentation, go to: http://integrallife.com/node/40930
where Integral Life provides a comprehensive review of Holosync and concludes it is a powerful addition to one's ILP.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
0 out of 0 members found this useful.
Don't read comments about Holosync....except this one!
Posted May 21st, 2010 by Martin SchoenO.K., I just did a little review of the blog posts that come up when you type "Holosync" into the Integral Life search engine. As many of you probably know, there's a diversity of opinions and experiences with Holosync.
Based on my training and experience as a psychologist, I would recommend that anyone new to Holosync not read these comments as they can have too much influence on your subsequent experience, i.e., don't pay attention to the posts--including mine (O.K., a pause while your mind fumbles with that one! ;-) ) Instead, I recommend you simply try it and, if you find it helpful, keep using it. If you have questions, call the Centerpointe support coaches.
I think this sort of personal growth practice and technology is too complex to let a few comments sway you. I suppose that's true of all profound processes of change, no?! We all want answers before we take a step; indeed, that was why I started this thread. The first level of the program, Awakening Prologue, has a money-back guarantee, so if you're intrigued and you trust Integral Life and their tutorial, give it a go.
Or not.
- Please Login to Add Comments
- Report Abuse
Please Log in to Vote.
1 out of 1 members found this useful.
Don't waste your money
Posted May 30th, 2010 by Roshana ArielYou can find other brain entrainment recordings that are just as good for MUCH less money.








.jpg)
Please Log in to Vote.
3 out of 3 members found this useful.
Holosync
Posted October 19th, 2008 by Jim ONeillHi Martin: I have been using Holosync for 9 months. I have not gone to the deeper levels yet. Bill Harris put together a response to Eckart Tolle and Oprah's discussions on the internet. He interviewed Ken Wilber, Genpo Roshi, Diane Hamilton and all spoke favorably of Holosync. www.masteringthepowerofnow.com Check out this link and see what you think.
Jim