Nick Hedlund calls the metacrisis a forcing function for humanity’s self-understanding, asking us to rethink what reality is, what a human being is, what nature and the sacred are. Visionary Realism is his answer: a philosophical framework built as a root level response to the metacrisis in service of radical planetary flourishing, forged by putting two serious traditions, Roy Bhaskar’s critical realism and Ken Wilber’s integral theory, into sustained dialogue, letting each transfigure the other into something genuinely new.
In this IAM Research Forum session, Hedlund walks through what each tradition gets right on its own (critical realism’s depth ontology, integral theory’s map of human development) and where each runs out of road, building toward the four core ideas of Visionary Realism: pandimensional realism, a new science of interiority, transcendental evolutionary realism, and alethic resonance, the idea that our worldviews and institutions need to stay in tune with reality itself.
Watch or listen · 1:31:15
Nicholas Hedlund, Brendan
Nicholas Hedlund
“Thanks so much, Brendan.”
Chapters (9)
Held with integral theory
Where they meet. Visionary Realism grew out of the dialogue between integral theory and critical realism, and Hedlund keeps much of integral. He calls Wilber’s *Integral Psychology* “arguably the most developed aspect of integral theory” and its map of developmental structures “an absolutely indispensable contribution.” His objection is to the ground beneath it: integral, he says, is strong at synthesizing the sciences and “not as strong” on philosophical ontology.
Does being contain knowing?
The challenge. Hedlund agrees with Wilber that being and knowing can’t be split apart. He objects to how Wilber joins them. In its Wilber-5 phase, he argues, integral “implodes the distinction” between ontology and epistemology, which doesn’t solve the problem and “just kind of like radicalizes it.” Visionary Realism proposes an asymmetrical unity instead: being contains knowing, “so that knowing is a subset of the world of being.”
The reply. In his 2015 Integral Theory Conference keynote, Wilber set out his version of the unity. Truth grows level by level within “a total wholeness of reality in which epistemology and ontology, inside and outside, are two aspects of the same underlying, unfolding wholeness.” Only this way, he said, can realism and enactivism “both be fully acknowledged and fully integrated.”
“And all of these can be expected to grow and evolve and thus make more truth at each higher level.”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
Where it lands. A real difference. Wilber keeps an asymmetry between levels (take away atoms and “molecules are dead”), but his being and knowing stand level, as two aspects of one whole, and for him every holon has an inside. Hedlund holds that there is “a level of ontology that does not include epistemology.” From it he draws Bhaskar’s ecological asymmetry: we depend on nature for our existence, and nature does not depend on us. He uses that asymmetry to judge an economy built on “infinite growth.”
Can an argument reach Spirit?
The challenge. Visionary Realism leans on transcendental arguments. Hedlund argues that development is built into “the very fabric of the cosmos” and that “we can transcendentally retroduce that,” and he credits Bhaskar with grounding the nondual in such arguments. Integral’s strongest line here is Wilber’s: on the deepest questions “the intellect pushes right up against its own boundaries,” and “the answer is given by another mode of knowing,” the nondual knowing of satori.
“And what I really think happens at that point is that we exhaust the limit of our intellectual mind and, you know, just open to our intuitive mind or transrational…”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
The reply. Hedlund doesn’t ask argument to work alone. A science of interiority, he says, can study the inner world in first, second and third person. It can join Bhaskar’s arguments with “Wilber’s idea of a deep empiricism,” a contemplative phenomenology “taken seriously as the kind of empirical element.”
Where it lands. A real difference, narrower than it looks. Both count contemplative experience as evidence. Hedlund also asks transcendental argument to show what must be real, while Wilber says that at this edge “you could state its opposite with just as much believability.” It decides whether a science of interiority can make its case to people who haven’t done the practice.
What holding both shows. Held together, integral says who can see a structure and Visionary Realism says the structure was there to be seen. Hedlund turns integral on critical realism too: its “cognitive maturity fallacy” assumes anyone could “pick up a Bhaskar book” and act on it, without the developmental scaffolding integral maps. The first exchange leaves a question for Whitehead’s process thought, also in this series: is there any being without some inside?
About Nicholas Hedlund
Nicholas Hedlund, PhD, is a visionary philosopher working at the nexus of philosophy of science, worldviews, and socioecological transformation. He received his PhD in philosophy and social sciences from University College London, studying under the philosopher Roy Bhaskar. Nicholas also holds a master’s degree in philosophy & religion, as well as one in psychology. He is director of Eudaimonia Institute, an emerging social innovations lab for planetary flourishing.

