This is a rich, cross-disciplinary exploration for those interested in: systems thinking, big history, evolution, complexity science, Gaia theory, and metatheory.
Tyler Volk (NYU Professor Emeritus) brings together work from his books Metapatterns, Gaia’s Body, and Quarks to Culture.
Watch or listen · 33:38
Tyler Volk
Tyler Volk
“Okay.”
Chapters (3)
Held with integral theory
Where they meet. Volk climbs from quarks to culture by what he calls combogenesis: “things in relations build a new thing” with new relations of its own. Wilber’s holons climb the same ladder, each whole a part of the next. Gregg Henriques, who has written with Volk, calls holons “very closely related” to this kind of building up.
Does a systems map see only the outside?
The challenge. Wilber values systems theory and places it in the Lower Right: collective realities seen from outside. His charge is that it took itself to include all reality, because it grew up while the Enlightenment was reducing everything to that one quadrant. He calls this subtle reductionism. A map of patterns and relations from quarks to culture invites the same test.
“What we're working with in the lower right is system theory.”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
The reply. Volk says his relations are not only physical. “They could be your mind having an idea of something you want to write about.” His systemese is also a set of shapes, like the container and the path, that minds think with, “and maybe that nature uses also.”
Where it lands. A real difference. Volk brings the mind in as relations and as the shapes thought takes, and Wilber counts that kind of structural study as one valid way to know the Upper Left. What the map has no place for yet is the view from within, and how what a mind can see changes as the knower grows.
Is evolution one process?
The challenge. Volk warns that people use “evolution” very loosely, for “any kind of trend.” He wants the kind named, such as propagation, variation and selection, so we can ask how each step happens in a mind, a culture or a species. His Gaia work shows why: organisms living on each other’s wastes amplify life about 200 times, yet “the end result was not selected for in any kind of way.” Volk does not name Wilber, but his point asks what integral’s Eros adds to the dynamics we can trace.
The reply. Wilber holds that chance and selection cannot account for the rise in complexity and wholeness since the Big Bang. “There’s some force in the universe that’s moving against chance,” he says, and “that force is eros.” Science sees it from outside as self-organization; it also shows up as deeper forms of “we” and a growing capacity of consciousness.
“So all of this is a staggering increase in complexity and unity and wholeness. And as for chance, it's exactly what it isn't.”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
Where it lands. A real difference. Both deny that selection explains everything. For Volk, the upward trend is the outcome of particular dynamics, each to be traced. For Wilber, it is one drive seen from three sides. Whether Eros explains the trend or only names it stays open, and integral’s claim that evolution has a direction rests on the answer.
What holding both shows. Volk models culture as two tiers of propagation, variation and selection: one in each mind, coupled to one in the group’s “agreement systems.” Integral could read those tiers as the Upper Left and Lower Left seen as dynamics, and add the inside view of each. Lawrence Cahoone calls his orders of nature “similar to Tyler Volk,” and Henriques draws on Volk’s “trail of combogenesis.” Volk leaves open whether our systemese is one “that nature uses also.” Integral’s answer, that every pattern has an inside, is one way to take up his question.
About Tyler Volk
Tyler Volk is Emeritus Professor of Biology and Environmental Studies at New York University, where he received the Distinguished Teaching Award and the Golden Dozen Award. At NYU he taught courses including "Lessons from the Biosphere" and an advanced honors seminar, "Metapatterns: From Quarks to Culture." He is the author of Metapatterns Across Space, Time, and Mind; Gaia's Body: Toward a Physiology of Earth; CO2 Rising: The Earth's Greatest Environmental Challenge; and, with a co-author, Death and Sex. He plays lead guitar for The Amygdaloids.