Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm joins Nick Hedlund and Brendan Graham Dempsey for a deep dive into metamodernism. Where does a worldview actually live, in an individual or in a culture, and what do we do with the fact that people are rarely as consistent as the concept assumes? Does a false belief become real the moment it makes something happen? How does a theory of language written for scholars end up shaping the way a whole country argues about facts? The answers keep turning on ontology, and on what “real” is being contrasted with in any given sentence, a question Storm thinks most of us skip. And what does any of this ask of us in the middle of a metacrisis?
Watch or listen · 1:15:45
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm, Brendan Graham Dempsey, Nicholas Hedlund
Brendan Graham Dempsey
“do it cool so one thing well one thing I'll start with here”
Chapters (7)
Held with integral theory
Where they meet. Storm likes the word metatheory, “a second order theory that looks at other kinds of theories as its content,” which is integral’s own self-description. He accepts the metacrisis framing (“That’s fine with me”) and says entangled crises call for “big picture thinking precisely now.” And he grants Hedlund that the postmodernism taught from anthologies held “a performative contradiction,” the charge Wilber has pressed for decades.
What unit has a worldview?
The challenge. Brendan Graham Dempsey asked whether metamodernism is a worldview. Storm distrusts the word, which integral uses for each of its stages. He rejects the picture behind it, a self inside the head looking out at a separate world. And he doubts the unit: people “are not that consistent,” taking beliefs “from here and a little bit from over there,” and it is unclear whether a worldview belongs to a person or a culture.
The reply. Wilber does not expect people to be consistent either. A person has a dozen or so lines of development, he says, and “you can be essentially at different levels in almost any of those lines”; thinking often runs a stage or two ahead of where a person actually lives. Elsewhere he calls the quadrants “the opposite” of Cartesian dualism: one event seen from several perspectives.
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
Where it lands. On the Cartesian picture, a matter of wording: both reject it. On consistency, a real difference. Integral expects unevenness between lines but a fixed order within each, and treats borrowed beliefs as surface content over a shared deep structure. Storm’s patchwork goes further. Hedlund answers in the podcast that a “worldview family” is an ideal type no one embodies cleanly; whether such mixed beliefs still share one structure is a question for research.
Is there one reality underneath?
The challenge. Asked by Dempsey whether reality is plural, Storm answered that existence is often dependent, as a hole depends on its donut, and that he has “trouble with notions of a unitary reality or existence or being.” Earlier in the same answer he called “a ground that’s a real ground” a mistake. Integral has one: for Wilber, Spirit is “the suchness or condition of all things.”
The reply. Wilber agrees that “almost all concepts that we use have meaning only in terms of their opposite,” close to Storm’s point that “real” is a contrastive word. That is why, he says, ultimate reality cannot be described. Following Nagarjuna, it is “radically unqualifiable,” neither empty nor not empty. It is known through awakening, apart from the science and reason that reach relative truths.
“In terms of how to even express that, it starts to get very, very tricky because almost all concepts that we use have meaning only in terms of their opposite.”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
Where it lands. A real difference. Both deny that the ultimate is one thing among things. But Wilber still calls it, in metaphor, “this absolute unity,” and holds that contemplatives can realize it. Storm’s modes of existence leave being plural and dependent, with nothing beneath them. Storm draws on Nagarjuna too, so the question stays open: is emptiness the ground of everything that arises, or the absence of any ground?
What holding both shows. Storm reads positivism and postmodernism as siblings, each with “different contradictions,” both splitting language from the world and giving it “tons of power.” Integral reads them as successive stages, orange and green, each true but partial. Held together they ask integral a fair question: can a later stage carry an earlier stage’s mistake forward, and how would a stage model notice? Visionary Realism, Hedlund’s project in this series, takes up Storm’s “real in contrast to what?” through Bhaskar’s “demi-real.”
About Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm is professor of religious studies and science and technology at Williams College. He received his master's degree from Harvard University and his PhD from Stanford University. His research focuses on Japanese religions, European intellectual history and theory more broadly. His book Metamodernism: The Future of Theory (2021) offers research methods for the humanities and social sciences that both radicalize and move beyond postmodernism.
About Nicholas Hedlund
Nicholas Hedlund, PhD, is a visionary philosopher working at the nexus of philosophy of science, worldviews, and socioecological transformation. He received his PhD in philosophy and social sciences from University College London, studying under the philosopher Roy Bhaskar. Nicholas also holds a master’s degree in philosophy & religion, as well as one in psychology. He is director of Eudaimonia Institute, an emerging social innovations lab for planetary flourishing.
About Brendan Graham Dempsey
Brendan Graham Dempsey is a writer whose work focuses on the meaning crisis and the nature of spirituality in metamodernity. He earned his BA in Religious Studies from the University of Vermont and his MA in Religion and the Arts from Yale University. His work has been deeply influenced by the writings of Ken Wilber and other integral thinkers. He lives in Greensboro Bend, Vermont, where he runs the holistic retreat center Sky Meadow.