Deep Structures & Surface Structures

Corey deVosPolarity Map

<< back to index

Polarity Description
The polarity between Deep Structures and Surface Structures represents a fundamental dynamic in integral thinking, crucial for a nuanced understanding of reality. This polarity underscores the interplay between the underlying, often implicit structures that govern systems (Deep Structures, sometimes called “deep features”) and their explicit, observable manifestations (Surface Structures, sometimes called “surface features”). Grasping this polarity allows us to see beyond surface phenomena to the underlying patterns that inform them, enhancing our ability to make sense of complex realities and adapt our thinking to accommodate both enduring principles and emergent trends.
 
Deep Structures are the intrinsic, often hidden structures, principles, or patterns that underpin and give rise to observable phenomena. They provide a stable, enduring foundation for our understanding of complex systems, whether in individual cognition, social dynamics, or natural processes. Deep Structures are crucial for theoretical clarity, offering a consistent framework that aids in analyzing and predicting outcomes based on foundational principles. They enable us to see beyond immediate appearances to the underlying architecture of reality, thus shaping our worldview and guiding our long-term strategic thinking.
 
Surface Structures are the observable, external manifestations of deep structures. They represent the dynamic, adaptable expressions of underlying principles, visible in everyday occurrences, behaviors, and societal trends. Surface Structures offer contextual relevance, ensuring that our understanding and applications of theories are adaptable and responsive to the immediate environment. They bring richness and diversity to our perception, allowing us to navigate and respond to the ever-changing landscape of reality. Understanding Surface Structures is key to practical application, innovation, and responsiveness in real-world scenarios.
“And so we can say: translation is a change in surface structures (‘horizontal’), whereas transformation is a change in deep structures (‘vertical’).”
Ken Wilber, Sex, Ecology, Spirituality
Example: Stages of Development

 
  • Deep Structure: The stages of development themselves (e.g., Magenta, Red, Amber, Umber, Orange, Green, Teal, Turquoise), each stage encompassing specific psychological and cognitive qualities that are universal to all human beings, in whatever culture we find them in.

  • Surface Structure: The diverse ways these stages manifest in culture, society, and individual experiences. For instance, two individuals at the same developmental stage might express the qualities of that stage very differently based on their personal experiences, cultural background, and social context. Similarly, a society or culture might reflect a particular stage in various ways through its laws, norms, art, and organizational structures.


This example underscores that while there may be a finite number of developmental stages (Deep Structures), the expressions of these stages (Surface Structures) are incredibly diverse and multifaceted. This diversity is not just across individuals but also within the same individual across different contexts and times. Understanding this dynamic allows for a more flexible and inclusive approach to personal growth, social analysis, and cultural understanding.

Integrated Polarity
Harmonious Transcription represents the integrated polarity where Deep Features (the structural essence or principles of a concept) and Surface Features (the observable and practical manifestations of these principles) are in a dynamic, coherent interplay. If deep structures refer to the floors of a building, and surface structures refer to the arrangement of furniture on each floor, then “transcriptive harmony” means ensuring that each floor is furnished and arranged appropriately according to its specific purpose, symbolizing how core patterns and principles are actualized in varied, context-sensitive ways.
 
In Harmonious Transcription there’s an ongoing process of aligning the deeper, often abstract and universal aspects of knowledge with their practical, observable expressions. This harmonious integration acknowledges that while deep structures provide the guiding principles and frameworks, it’s through their thoughtful translation into surface structures that these principles become relevant, useful, and meaningful in real-world contexts, ensuring a healthy or appropriate arrangement of surface structures for the underlying deep structures at play.
“We can use our simple analogy of the three-story building to summarize all of these definitions. Each of the three main floors is a deep structure; the furniture, chairs, and tables on each floor are the surface structures. Rearranging the furniture on any given floor is translation; changing floors is transformation. (And the relation of the furniture to each floor is transcription.)”Ken Wilber, Sex Ecology Spirituality
Disintegrated Polarity
In this disintegrated polarity, an overemphasis on Deep Features leads to an overgeneralized universalist approach that may overlook specific, contextual nuances and practical applications. This can result in rigid, broad-stroke, one-size-fits-all solutions that fail to address the unique aspects and variability of individual situations. Conversely, an overemphasis on Surface Features leads to superficial analysis that results from a fixation on the minutiae and variability of specific contexts, potentially resulting in a fragmented understanding that lacks a unifying framework or guiding principles. This approach can cause one to be mired in the details, unable to see the broader picture or connect the dots effectively.
 
Both extremes — the overly generalized approach of deep structures and the overly particularized or relativized focus on surface structures — represent a lack of integral balance. They demonstrate the necessity of harmonizing Deep and Surface Features to achieve a comprehensive, adaptable, and effective understanding and application of concepts.
Tips for Harmonizing
To harmonize the emphasis on Deep and Surface Features in our thinking and analysis, it’s crucial to strike a balance between the underlying principles and their practical manifestations. This harmonization involves ensuring that our understanding is neither too abstract and disconnected from reality (overemphasis on Deep Features) nor too fragmented and lacking in foundational coherence (overemphasis on Surface Features). The goal is to create a synergy where deep structural insights inform and are informed by surface-level observations, leading to a more comprehensive and practical understanding.
 
  • Adopt a Both/And Mindset: Cultivate a mindset that embraces both deep structural insights and surface-level observations. Instead of viewing them as either/or propositions, recognize that a comprehensive understanding often requires a both/and approach.
  • Use Comparative Analysis: Regularly compare and contrast how a situation or concept manifests at both the deep structural level and the surface level. This practice can help illuminate differences and similarities, leading to a more nuanced understanding.
  • Mindful Shifting: Consciously practice shifting your focus from deep to surface features and back again. This can be done during problem-solving sessions, brainstorming, or reflective thinking, where you intentionally alternate between exploring underlying principles and their practical implications.
  • Practice Integrative Thinking: Develop the habit of integrative thinking — the ability to hold and integrate multiple, and sometimes conflicting, ideas in your mind simultaneously. This skill is crucial for balancing and aligning deep and surface features.
  • Use Comparative Analysis: Regularly compare and contrast how a situation or concept manifests at both the deep structural level and the surface level. This practice can help illuminate differences and similarities, leading to a more nuanced understanding.
Tips for Integrating
The goal of integrating both deep structures and surface structures in our thinking and sense-making is to embody healthy transcription — the process where deep structural principles (Deep Structures) are effectively and appropriately expressed in practical, context-specific scenarios (Surface Structures). This involves not only understanding and applying these deep principles but also adapting and translating them skillfully and appropriately to fit various real-world contexts. The aim is to create a dynamic, evolving understanding where the abstract and the concrete, the universal and the particular, inform and enrich each other.
 
  • Develop Dynamic Flexibility: Cultivate the ability to fluidly move between deep structural understanding and surface-level observation. This means being able to zoom in on details when necessary, but also zoom out to grasp the broader, foundational principles that connect these details.
  • Practice Reflective Synthesis: Regularly take time to synthesize your observations and insights. Reflect on how specific instances and practical experiences align with or challenge the deep structural principles you are working with. This reflective synthesis helps in continuously refining both your understanding of deep structures and your interpretation of surface phenomena.
  • Embrace Iterative Learning: Recognize that the process of transcription is iterative. Your initial understanding of how deep principles translate into surface features will evolve as you gain more experience and insights. Be open to revising your interpretations and applications as you gather more information.
  • Mindful Observation: Practice mindful observation in your daily life. Observe how deep structures, patterns, and principles are at play in everyday situations, as well as how these deep structures manifest as surface structures and patterns, and reflect on these observations. This practice helps in grounding abstract concepts into tangible experiences, while better understanding how universal patterns can manifest in countless different varieties from one context to the next.

Related Media

Holons: The Building Blocks of the Universe

Corey deVos

Join Corey deVos for this fun, fascinating, and far-reaching exploration of one of the essential cornerstones of integral theory — holons, or the apparently endless series of “part/wholes” that fundamentally compose reality as we know it. Accompanied by music, imagery, and animation, this presentation will not only help you better understand what a holon actually is (and what it isn’t!) but also how this understanding can radically deepen your appreciation for the natural world, and for all of the other holonic intelligences that exist alongside us on this planet.


From Polarization to Integration

Ken Wilber and Corey deVos

Ken Wilber and Corey deVos explore some of the causal factors behind so many of the regressive tendencies in our culture and politics these days, from new social pressures coming from social media technologies like Facebook, to the historic evolutionary trends that have formed and informed our major schools of political thought in the first place.


Recommended Training


 
with Beena Sharma
 
Integrating Polarities is a revolutionary new training program by Beena Sharma, designed to teach you the higher-order thinking common to leading-edge individuals at the integral stage of development. This training is designed to model the higher-order thinking associated with integral stages of psychological maturity, offering you a step-by-step process to help you learn these thinking skills and apply them to your life, your relationships, and your work in the world.
 
Enroll Now

More Polarity Maps

About Corey deVos

Corey W. deVos is editor and producer of Integral Life. He has worked for Integral Institute/Integal Life since Spring of 2003, and has been a student of integral theory and practice since 1996. Corey is also a professional woodworker, and many of his artworks can be found in his VisionLogix art gallery.