Integrative Metatheories: Alfred North Whitehead’s Process Philosophy

Andrew M. DavisInstitute of Applied Metatheory

In this wide-ranging IAM Research Forum session, Andrew M. Davis introduces process philosophy and the metaphysics of Alfred North Whitehead. Whitehead spent his first career as a mathematician, co-writing Principia Mathematica, and turned to metaphysics only in his sixties, after Harvard offered him a chair in philosophy. What came of that turn was a philosophy insisting that nothing in experience may be left out, that certainty is folly, and that value is something nature proclaims to us rather than something we project onto it. Those claims get their fullest expression in Process and Reality, the 1929 Gifford Lectures that made his name synonymous with process philosophy, where he holds that “the elucidation of immediate experience is the sole justification for any thought.”

Watch or listen · 1:26:27

Andrew M. Davis, Brendan

Andrew M. Davis

“Hard to do initially,”

0:00 / 1:26:27

Chapters (7)

Held with integral theory

Where they meet. Wilber builds his account of each moment on Whitehead’s: a new subject prehends the one before, making it an object, and adds a bit of novelty. Both see interiors all the way down. Davis even describes constructive postmodernism, the process answer to modernity, as an effort to “transcend but include” it.

Can a metaphysics outlive its time?

The challenge. Integral calls itself post-metaphysical. Wilber says he isn’t denying metaphysics; he wants to “get really close to what we already know is happening.” Even the great systems of Plotinus and Aurobindo, he says, were interpretations of their makers’ experience, shaped by the science and culture of their time. Whitehead’s scheme reaches further, to the experience of electrons and the nature of God. Integral would ask what keeps it from being one more beautiful interpretation of its day.

“you know? Keep in this place. Remember when somebody like Plotinus or Orvino postulated the great systems of integral thinking, which they did, and are still things of absolute unexcelled…”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

A Natural History of Supernormal Powers · 2003

The reply. The scheme is built to be tested. Whitehead compares his method to an airplane’s flight: it starts from “the ground of a particular observation,” rises into “imaginative generalization,” and lands again “for renewed observation.” Whitehead also calls metaphysics “an experimental adventure” and its categories tentative.

Integrative Metatheories: Alfred North Whitehead’s Process Philosophy · 2026

Where it lands. A real difference in the test, since both are fallibilists. Whitehead tests a scheme by its coherence and its fit with all of experience at once. Wilber wants claims that can be “confirmed or rejected” by anyone who does the practice, so he keeps metaphysics small. The test cuts both ways: integral also gives atoms prehension, which no practice reaches, and may need Whitehead’s flight to justify it.

Is the deepest ground process, or emptiness?

The challenge. Wilber places Whitehead’s God inside the world of form. All of manifestation, he says, “subsists in the low causal as the sum total of the consequent and primordial nature of spirit in roughly Whitehead’s sense.” Past it lies “the causal formless,” which “never itself enters the world of form.” So integral would say process thought maps form, with God in it, and leaves out the emptiness Wilber calls “the deepest depth of this and every moment.”

“The totality of all manifestation at any time, the all, subsists in the low causal as the sum total of the consequent and primordial nature of spirit in roughly Whitehead's…”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Tipping Points and the Eye of Contemplation · 2011

The reply. Whitehead never made flux the whole story. Davis reads his gloss on the hymn “Abide with me; fast falls the eventide”: the first line gives the permanences, the second the flux, and “the two lines cannot be torn apart.” The permanences in the passage run from the mountains to “the spirit of man” and God.

Integrative Metatheories: Alfred North Whitehead’s Process Philosophy · 2026

Where it lands. A real difference. Whitehead’s permanences have character: God, and what Davis in the follow-up talk calls “platonic-like domains” of possibility and value. Wilber’s formless is no permanent thing at all, and he holds that it is known directly in contemplation. Whitehead’s rule that nothing may be omitted, “experience drunk and experience sober,” means process thought must place those reports. For Wilber they point past both process and permanence.

What holding both shows. The two already share a working part: Wilber reads Whitehead’s “creative advance into novelty” as the play of Spirit. Process offers integral a method for its own speculative claims, the airplane flight, which a forum member heard as close to critical realism. Integral offers process the states that disclose the formless. Held together, they ask whether the new rises within the flux or from a depth beneath it.

About Andrew M. Davis

Andrew M. Davis is an American process philosopher, theologian and scholar of the cosmos. He is research and academic director for the Center for Process Studies, where he researches, writes, teaches and organizes conferences on process-relational thought. He is author, editor or co-editor of over a dozen books, including Mind, Value, and Cosmos: On the Relational Nature of Ultimacy (2020), Process Cosmology: New Integrations in Science and Philosophy (2022), Metaphysics of Exo-Life: Toward a Constructive Whiteheadian Cosmotheology (2023) and Whitehead's Universe: A Prismatic Introduction (2026).