Natural Philosophy 2.0: Rebuilding a Coherent Worldview

Gregg HenriquesInstitute of Applied Metatheory

The IAM Research Forum is a new recurring space for our scholarly community. As things progress, these sessions will serve as opportunities for our scholars to present their work, share updates from working groups, and discuss projects moving towards publication.

In this session, Gregg Henriques presents Natural Philosophy 2.0: a proposal for reviving natural philosophy as a unifying framework capable of integrating modern science, mind, meaning, and value into a coherent worldview.

Dr. Henriques argues that while modern science provides an increasingly sophisticated cosmology, it still fails to offer a fully integrated worldview — particularly when it comes to mind, consciousness, value, and lived human experience. To address this, he introduces a directional framing (down / back / up / over, with out-and-in) for situating empirical science, emergence, evolutionary history, psychology, and meaning-making within a single orienting structure.

The discussion ranges across emergence and downward causation, big history and “combogenesis,” the problem of psychology, critical realism, information-processing revolutions, and how a renewed natural philosophy might help bridge the Enlightenment gap between objective knowledge and subjective life.

The second half of the session opens into an extended Q&A, where IAM scholars discuss the proposal in real time — pressing on questions of emergence and downward causation, critical realism, big history and combogenesis, the “problem of psychology,” information-processing revolutions, and how these ideas translate into lived understanding.

Discussion contributors include: Bonnitta Roy, Lawrence Cahoone, Mark Edwards, Michael Mascolo, Nick Hedlund, Brendan Graham Dempsey, Robb Smith, and Tyler Volk.

Gregg Henriques is a clinical psychologist, theoretical psychologist, and the originator of the Unified Theory of Knowledge (UTOK), a transdisciplinary framework developed to address the longstanding fragmentation between the natural sciences, psychology, and the humanities. He is a core scholar affiliated with the Institute of Applied Metatheory (IAM) and has spent decades working at the intersection of psychology, philosophy, and metatheory.

Watch or listen · 1:46:44

Gregg Henriques

“And here's the logo.”

0:00 / 1:46:44

Chapters (9)

Held with integral theory

Where they meet. Henriques argues that modern science gives us “a cosmology” and no worldview, because its method is designed “to factor out subjective and social forms of knowing.” He calls this the Enlightenment gap. Wilber told a similar story in *The Marriage of Sense and Soul*: modernity rightly differentiated art, morals and science, then let them drift into dissociation, with the inner domains reduced to their outer correlates.

Can a map of perspectives reach back to nature?

The challenge. Asked whether the social sciences already place us in a world of first-, second- and third-person experience, Henriques said yes, “epistemologically.” But starting from the social world leaves “an ontological break,” the physical and biological world below and the social world above. The test is to show how a frame “gets back down to the natural sciences.” Integral starts from the same perspectives, and elsewhere Henriques says he critiques Wilber’s way of doing it “ontologically.”

Natural Philosophy 2.0: Rebuilding a Coherent Worldview · 2026

The reply. Wilber rejects such a break too, and finds it in other maps: they list individual holons from atoms to brains, then stack family, tribe and nation on top. For him social holons form “as soon as there’s an atom,” from galaxies to star clusters to planets, in one evolutionary unfolding.

“And usually what happens is people, when they're creating their hierarchies, they give individual holons first. So they go atoms, molecules, cells, complex organisms, organisms with a triumvirate brain.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Morphic Fields, Memory, and the Creative Advance · 2008

Where it lands. A real difference, narrower than it looks. Neither leaves society floating above nature. Henriques wants a mechanism the sciences can test at each joint; Wilber offers a pattern found at every level and leaves the mechanisms to each science.

Is mind its own dimension of nature?

The challenge. Henriques says the big-history picture is missing two categories: mindedness, and “the jump from primates to persons.” Without them, he says, “you’re clapping with one hand.”

Natural Philosophy 2.0: Rebuilding a Coherent Worldview · 2026

The reply. Wilber does name mind, as the inside of every level. In his account consciousness and form “evolve together”: prehension in atoms, then a deeper interior with each new exterior, from neural nets to “reptilian brain stems” to “paleomammalian limbic systems.”

“Their consciousness is the interior and the exterior material forms are the right-hand quadrants, and these go together. They evolve together.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Integral Ecology: Uniting Multiple Perspectives on the Natural World · 2009

Where it lands. A real difference. Both refuse a world that jumps from brain to culture with nothing named in between. For Henriques, mind is a new dimension of nature that begins with animals and their behavior. For Wilber, it is the interior of every holon, deepening level by level, so there is no single point where mind begins.

Do only humans have culture?

The challenge. UTOK keeps its fourth plane, Culture-Person, for humans and their systems of justification. Integral uses “culture” for the shared interior of any group, at every level. Reading the zones of an animal, Wilber calls the animal’s Lower Left “a cultural organism, a first-person plural.” Field studies show animal groups keeping their own traditions: when Aplin and colleagues seeded two foraging techniques into wild great-tit groups, each group held to its local one across two generations (*Nature*, 2015).

“one hyphen P, that's resonating interior to interior with another sentient being. And the question there is in what ways does the animal share depth and exchange meaning with others?”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Integral Ecology: Uniting Multiple Perspectives on the Natural World · 2009

The reply. Henriques has not answered this on record. When a forum member raised research on animal social structure and social learning, he granted it, “We clearly do,” and turned to psychology’s missing ontology. His nearest words are on Vygotsky, who showed “culture is popping out in humans differently than animals.”

Natural Philosophy 2.0: Rebuilding a Coherent Worldview · 2026

Where it lands. Mostly a matter of wording. Both see something new arrive with human language and justification, and both grant that animals share a social life. UTOK names that human plane Culture; integral uses culture for the shared interior at every level, and its own word is loose too, since traditions like the great tits’ are shared behavior, which integral places in the Lower Right. A smaller question stays open: is the human jump a new dimension of nature or a new stage of a shared interior every level already has? Labels decide what a map makes visible, and here each map hides something the other names.

What holding both shows. Henriques adds two joints to the big-history picture, mindedness and justification. Integral could take them as finer joints in its map of levels and bring the perspectives that ask who is looking, and whose group is speaking. Henriques also lined the Tree of Knowledge up with Lawrence Cahoone’s orders of nature, another system in this series.

About Gregg Henriques

Gregg Henriques is Professor of Graduate Psychology at James Madison University and a clinical and theoretical psychologist. He is the founder of UTOK, the Unified Theory of Knowledge, a system that bridges the sciences and humanities, and the author of UTOK: The Unified Theory of Knowledge (2024), A New Synthesis for Solving the Problem of Psychology (2022) and A New Unified Theory of Psychology (2011). He writes the Theory of Knowledge blog for Psychology Today. He is a fellow of the American Psychological Association and a licensed clinical psychologist in Virginia.