Ordinal Naturalism: Emergence, Reality & the Orders of Nature

Lawrence CahooneInstitute of Applied Metatheory

The IAM Research Forum is a new recurring space for our scholarly community. As things progress, these sessions will serve as opportunities for our scholars to present their work, share updates from working groups, and discuss projects moving towards publication.

Dr. Lawrence Cahoone introduces Ordinal Naturalism — his non-reductive account of nature that integrates hierarchical systems theory, emergence, and Justus Buchler’s pluralistic metaphysics of “natural complexes.”

Beginning with an outline of the five “orders” of nature — physical, material, biological, mental, and cultural — Cahoone presents them both as distinct domains of phenomena and as stages in the historical evolution of nature, marked by increasing complexity over time.

From there, he retraces the philosophical path that leads to this view: from Columbia Naturalism and objective relativism, through the late-20th-century rejection of foundationalism, to contemporary theories of emergence and partial reduction (Wimsatt, Anderson, Simon, Kauffman, and others).

Watch or listen · 44:47

Lawrence Cahoone

Lawrence Cahoone

“object and yell and criticize i know you won't yell but uh i just have to say i guarantee you um i'm a philosopher i guarantee you that nothing you could possibly say could be as upsetting as what my colleagues usually say to me so um let's go ahead”

0:00 / 44:47

Chapters (4)

Held with integral theory

Where they meet. Cahoone’s five orders of nature, physical, material, biological, mental and cultural, are levels of complexity and also stages in nature’s history. Wilber’s holarchy tells a similar story, and both reject reductionism and a split between mind and nature. Both give the lower levels a priority that is not a rank in reality. For Cahoone, physics “applies to more of the universe,” yet “neither is more real than the other.” For Wilber, atoms are more fundamental than cells, and cells more significant.

Where does the inside begin?

The challenge. Integral holds that every holon has an inside as well as an outside. Wilber says that when we describe molecules, cells and nervous systems in third-person terms, “we’re leaving out the interiors.” Cahoone’s orders follow the sciences, and mind enters fourth. Integral would ask whether such a map finds the inside only where it shows from outside.

“that is alive. And I think that every single phenomenon does have. both an interior and an exterior. And those, of course, are the left-hand quadrants and the right-hand quadrants.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Nature Mysticism: The Re-Enchantment of the World · 2011

The reply. Cahoone gives the inside full reality. Following Justus Buchler, he holds that nothing is more real than anything else, and our dreams are real. The way train tracks seem to meet in the distance is real too, “a perspectival representation,” but it can occur only in “a living organism with visual perception.”

Ordinal Naturalism: Emergence, Reality & the Orders of Nature · 2026

Where it lands. A real difference. Wilber accepts emergence too, as simple insides growing into complex ones. He calls his view “pan-interiorism,” with the simple feeling Whitehead called prehension at the base, and he doubts consciousness can appear, “pow,” from what has none. Cahoone places perspective with living things and, following William Wimsatt, treats emergence as what is left once partial reductions are done. So is the inside a late order of nature, or a face of every order?

Is Spirit a claim about the whole?

The challenge. Asked whether Buchler would reject a non-dual ground of being, Cahoone said, “Completely.” His own view is milder. We can talk about the whole, but there “our claims must be the most tentative,” and no claim about the whole may overrule “what we encounter and experience and in the sciences.” Integral’s Kosmos has Spirit as its ground, so this goes to its base.

Ordinal Naturalism: Emergence, Reality & the Orders of Nature · 2026

The reply. For Wilber, Spirit is no guess about the whole. It is met in direct experience, as Bach or a sunset is, and those who have had it can describe it to one another well enough.

“People are sort of always saying, you know, mystical experience is inherently ineffable, indescribable. But all experiences are ultimately indescribable.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

13 Koans (And Their Answers) to Awaken Your Deepest Heart and Mind · 2013

Where it lands. A real difference, narrower than it looks. Cahoone’s rule protects what we experience, and Wilber’s claim is that realization is experience, checked by others who practice. The open question is whether a contemplative’s report tells us about the ground of nature or, as Buchler’s parity would have it, about one more experience. Cahoone did not take that up in the talk. That decides whether practice counts as evidence in metaphysics.

What holding both shows. Cahoone calls his orders “very similar” to Henriques’s UTOK, and similar to Tyler Volk’s work. Integral could use Wimsatt’s partial reduction as a careful account of the outside of each holon. Cahoone, after Morris Cohen, asks how a thing is real and in what order of relations. That is close to Wilber’s Kosmic address: even “infinite, formless Godhead has a Kosmic address,” he says, the formless causal state. Held together, the two maps could place a satori as Cahoone places a dream: real, and real somewhere in particular.

About Lawrence Cahoone

Lawrence Cahoone is Emeritus Professor of Philosophy at the College of the Holy Cross. He was formerly Associate Professor of Philosophy at Boston University and President of the Metaphysical Society of America. He has taught and written on social and political philosophy, philosophy of culture, metaphysics and natural science, and theories of modernism and postmodernism, drawing on analytic, continental and American philosophy. He describes himself as a systematic philosopher.