In this episode of the Integration podcast, Leigh Price sits down with Nick Hedlund and Brendan Graham Dempsey to go further into critical realism than her IAM Research Forum talk had room for. She traces Roy Bhaskar’s philosophy through its major phases, from transcendental realism through dialectical critical realism, where his concept of absence resolves long-standing puzzles in the Hegelian and Marxist dialectic.
From there, she unpacks what’s often called Bhaskar’s “spiritual turn,” the philosophy of metaReality: its account of non-duality and re-enchantment, and its debt to the African concept of Ubuntu. She also shares her own contribution to the field, an argument that critical realism functions as a form of systems theory, one it’s rarely been credited for.
Price describes the historic dialogues between critical realists and integral theorists, where real synthesis emerged alongside real tension, and recalls working alongside Bhaskar directly, including an unfinished chapter on human flourishing he asked her to write shortly before he died.
The episode closes on critical realism’s relevance to the metacrisis, including the case that most of us already reason like critical realists in practice, and what it would take to actually shift the root metaphors we use to make sense of the world.
Watch or listen · 1:08:54
Leigh Price, Nicholas Hedlund, Brendan Graham Dempsey
Nicholas Hedlund
“So yeah, to get started in your presentation, you went in more depth around kind of the basic critical realism,”
Chapters (6)
Held with integral theory
Where they meet. Price says Bhaskar “has almost done identical work” to Wilber’s, starting from a different place. Wilber surveyed the world’s philosophies and found four quadrants; Bhaskar, she says, “gives an ontology to those four quadrants and Wilber sort of described them.” If both describe reality, “there should somehow be a match,” and she thinks they “fit together quite well.”
How is a claim judged true?
The challenge. Price places the main difference in “how one judges truth.” She allows that integral theorists may have changed, but saw in the earlier work “a more Kantian kind of version of truth making,” in which the knower’s categories shape what is known. Bhaskar relies on judgmental rationality: rival theories are weighed by how well they explain what is there. Hedlund later recalls the dialogues finding in integral a neo-Kantian strain that “veers into the epistemic fallacy, arguably.”
The reply. Wilber’s answer, from his 2015 Integral Theory Conference keynote, is a “sliding scale of truth.” Each level of development sees a different world. If truth meant matching one pre-given world, no one would have it until evolution ended, and evolution never ends. So “each level is true, each higher level is more true.”
“As for that sliding scale of truth, The idea that each level is true, each higher level is more true.”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
Where it lands. A real difference, narrower than it looks. Both give up all-or-nothing truth: Price says fallibilism is built into Bhaskar’s philosophy, since new information can always change how we understand things. The difference is the anchor. Bhaskar judges theories against a world that stays put while our knowledge of it changes; Wilber ties each truth to the level that knows it.
Is getting lost in a book nondual?
The challenge. Wilber holds that Spirit is already present, so seeking it assumes it is missing. Still, he ranks the moments of flow. Absorption in the passing present, he says, is “the lowest form of flow state.” The timeless now is “going to take a little bit of a different type of practice.”
“completely beside the point. And as long as you're actually seeking spirit, then your assumption is spirit is not present. How else would you seek it?”
Ken Wilber
Become a member to hear it.
The reply. Price presents Bhaskar’s meta-Reality as starting from ordinary life. “We are often in a non-dual state,” she reports him saying: when we listen to someone, get “totally lost” in a book, or are in the flow Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi describes. Practice still matters: to grow, Bhaskar held, “you have to unthink.”
Where it lands. A real difference, narrower than it looks. Both treat the nondual as near at hand; they part on the everyday moments. For Bhaskar these are the nondual already at work in shared life. For Wilber they are real but shallow, and deeper states open through practice and are read through the stage of the one who has them. Price herself finds Bhaskar’s “ground state” “perhaps a little bit of a simplistic way of thinking about it.” The question is whether contemplative practice finds new depths or uncovers what was always there.
What holding both shows. Price thinks the quadrants match Bhaskar’s “seven layers of scale” better than his four planes of social being, a mapping still to be worked out. Hedlund recalls that Bhaskar, near the end of *Enlightened Common Sense*, called critical realism’s epistemology and its grasp of developmental psychology underdeveloped, which is where integral is strong. The tensions, Hedlund says, produced Complex Integral Realism and Visionary Realism, both in this series, and Price is “a bit sad” whenever critical realism is set against other metatheories, since Bhaskar worked to get past such splits.
About Leigh Price
Leigh Price is a Zimbabwean-born ecophilosopher who has worked mainly in environmental education. She is an Associate Professor at the Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences and a Research Associate of the Environmental Learning and Research Centre at Rhodes University, where she earned her PhD in environmental education. A former colleague of the critical realist philosopher Roy Bhaskar at the Institute of Education, University College London, she co-authored Interdisciplinarity and Wellbeing: A Critical Realist General Theory of Interdisciplinarity with Bhaskar and Berth Danermark. She has developed a philosophy for ecology that she calls "deep naturalism."
About Nicholas Hedlund
Nicholas Hedlund, PhD, is a visionary philosopher working at the nexus of philosophy of science, worldviews, and socioecological transformation. He received his PhD in philosophy and social sciences from University College London, studying under the philosopher Roy Bhaskar. Nicholas also holds a master’s degree in philosophy & religion, as well as one in psychology. He is director of Eudaimonia Institute, an emerging social innovations lab for planetary flourishing.
About Brendan Graham Dempsey
Brendan Graham Dempsey is a writer whose work focuses on the meaning crisis and the nature of spirituality in metamodernity. He earned his BA in Religious Studies from the University of Vermont and his MA in Religion and the Arts from Yale University. His work has been deeply influenced by the writings of Ken Wilber and other integral thinkers. He lives in Greensboro Bend, Vermont, where he runs the holistic retreat center Sky Meadow.