What Is Archdisciplinarity Really?

Cory David BarkerInstitute of Applied Metatheory

In this episode of the Integration podcast, Cory David Barker joins Nick Hedlund and Brendan Graham Dempsey to go deeper into archdisciplinarity, the study of what the big unifying frameworks have in common. It began with a puzzle: a universal model of structure and a universal model of process seemed to rest on the same underlying recursion, a pattern Barker traces back to Turing and Church. He explains why he writes his arches as theorems and axioms, so people can disagree with them one claim at a time, and why formal science is the field big-picture thinking has most neglected.

Is comparing frameworks a way of finding what they share, or of exposing where they break? And what is it like to live inside a picture of reality that, as Barker puts it, shouldn’t exist at all and yet is ridiculously organized?

Watch or listen · 1:15:50

Cory David Barker, Brendan Graham Dempsey, Nicholas Hedlund

Brendan Graham Dempsey

“Yeah, indeed.”

0:00 / 1:15:50

Chapters (7)

Held with integral theory

Where they meet. Barker found Wilber’s fulcrums while surveying developmental psychology, and he thinks Wilber has contributed more to this field “in the last hundred years than anyone else.” Both hold that development can be helped along but not skipped. Barker says “you can’t make societies skip stages,” only “hasten the process”; Wilber says nobody went from hunting and gathering to industry and “skipped horticultural and agrarian.”

Did Wilber line up the stages wrong?

The challenge. Barker thought Wilber “had most of it right” but made errors in organizing the stages. Sara Ross pointed him to Michael Commons, whose table of concordance aligns many stage models with the model of hierarchical complexity. That model, as Barker describes it, orders behavior by complexity, from actions to systems of actions and on up through metasystematic thinking. The concordance, he says, “solves all the issues that I had with how Wilber did it.”

What Is Archdisciplinarity Really? · 2026

The reply. Wilber’s charts in *Integral Psychology* set more than a hundred models, East and West, on one spectrum: the Western models of growing up from pre-personal to personal, and the meditative models of waking up above them. For the upper personal levels he uses Commons’s own stages: systemic for orange, metasystemic for green, paradigmatic for teal, and for turquoise the highest stage “orthodox developmentalists recognize.”

“So I take those levels of meditative development and simply put them on top of all the stages of growing up.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Growing Up: A Guided Tour · 2019

Where it lands. Closer than it sounds, then a real difference. Both line up many models against one scale, and from orange to turquoise Wilber’s scale is Commons’s. Barker doesn’t name the errors he found. One likely place: above turquoise, Wilber’s spectrum draws on contemplative models of waking up, which a measure of behavioral complexity doesn’t score. That decides whether the highest stages are new orders of complexity or a different kind of growth.

Can comparing maps settle what consciousness is?

The challenge. Nick Hedlund asked how a synthesis should fit consciousness, when UTOK, panpsychism, process thought and integral theory each treat it differently and a shared category doesn’t say which is right. Integral holds that some of it is settled by practice. Wilber’s three strands of good knowing hold for Zen as for chemistry: follow an injunction, have the experience it opens, and compare it with others who did the same.

“I gave one short approach to that by saying that genuine science, whether it's doing Zen, or it's doing chemistry, has at least three branches or three wings.”

Ken Wilber

Become a member to hear it.

Death Makes Life Possible · 2015

The reply. Barker doesn’t think “anybody knows the actual… instantiated truth of what is real in the universe,” and he wouldn’t “make a claim on one account or the other.” If people can show that consciousness is a universal class, “distributed across domains and scales,” he stays open to it even where he disagrees. He calls this an epoché, and says he is not a relativist.

What Is Archdisciplinarity Really? · 2026

Where it lands. A real difference. Both send claims to a test others can check. For Barker the test is a demonstration across the big pictures. For Wilber the deciding data on consciousness come from practice, and only those who have done the practice can confirm or reject them. That decides whether a meditator’s report counts as evidence inside an arch theory or waits outside it.

What holding both shows. Barker writes his arches as axioms and theorems that critics can accept or dispute one by one, and he calls them propositions open to falsification. Integral’s third strand asks the same of every claim, contemplative ones included, so the two could share a way of testing while they differ on what counts as data. Brendan Graham Dempsey closed by asking what it is like to live in the ruliad’s world, which Barker finds “ridiculously organized”: an Upper Left question that process philosophy and UTOK, also in this series, answer too.

About Cory David Barker

Cory David Barker is a transdisciplinary and archdisciplinary scholar. He holds a Master of Arts in Social Science and Informatics and is pursuing a PhD in cognitive science at the University of Jyväskylä in Finland, where his research applies big picture thinking to AGI design. He led the multi-author book Foundations of Archdisciplinarity, which aims to establish archdisciplinarity as the study of big picture, transdisciplinary, theory of everything and unification metatheoretical frameworks. He is President of the Archdisciplinary Research Center.

About Nicholas Hedlund

Nicholas Hedlund, PhD, is a visionary philosopher working at the nexus of philosophy of science, worldviews, and socioecological transformation. He received his PhD in philosophy and social sciences from University College London, studying under the philosopher Roy Bhaskar. Nicholas also holds a master’s degree in philosophy & religion, as well as one in psychology. He is director of Eudaimonia Institute, an emerging social innovations lab for planetary flourishing.

About Brendan Graham Dempsey

Brendan Graham Dempsey is a writer whose work focuses on the meaning crisis and the nature of spirituality in metamodernity. He earned his BA in Religious Studies from the University of Vermont and his MA in Religion and the Arts from Yale University. His work has been deeply influenced by the writings of Ken Wilber and other integral thinkers. He lives in Greensboro Bend, Vermont, where he runs the holistic retreat center Sky Meadow.