Life as Practice: Karma Yoga and Awakening Service

This Integral Life Practice module was lovingly produced for Integral Life members.

Become a member now for just $1 for the first 30 days, get access to hundreds of perspectives, practices, videos, and audio recordings, and support the global Integral Movement.

Start Your Integral Life

Karma Yoga and Awakening Service: Modern Approaches to an Ancient Practice

by Roger Walsh

Continuous unbroken practice is widely regarded across the world’s contemplative traditions as essential for rapid progress and advanced development. The challenge is therefore how to use daily activities as part of one’s practice. The answer is given systematically in Hinduism’s discipline of karma yoga: the yoga of work and action in the world. However, traditional instructions are somewhat vague and are not specifically oriented towards service. This article (and video) therefore offers a more detailed and precise ten step program by which all activities can be used for both contemplative practice and service, and thereby become a practice that can be called “awakening service”.

Our contemporary global crises are also global symptoms of, in part, our individual and collective psychological immaturities and pathologies. Addressing these crises effectively will therefore require addressing both the external problems—such as nuclear weapons and ecological destruction—as well as their psychological and cultural roots. Karma yoga and awakening service may therefore be valuable practices for working with social and global issues.

The Context and Crises of Our Times

We live and work and serve in a unique time: a time of global crisis that is unprecedented in scope and complexity and that threatens both our planet and our species.

We are all aware of the major elements of this crisis: elements such as population explosion, ecological degradation, species extinction, and weapons of mass destruction. What is crucial to recognize about these challenges is that for the first time in history, the major threats to human survival and wellbeing are all human caused. Like the sorcerer’s apprentice, humankind now possess enormous power but little wisdom, and it is no exaggeration to say that humankind is now in a race between consciousness and catastrophe (Elgin, 2013).

So great is our power that the state of the world now reflects the state of our minds and the problems around us now reflect the problems within us and between us. What we call our global problems are actually global symptoms.

Therefore, if we are going to preserve our planet and our species we certainly need to feed the hungry, stop pollution, and reduce weapons of war. But if we only do this, we are only treating symptoms. We also need to address their underlying developmental, psychological, spiritual, social and cultural causes. In short, we need an integral approach (Wilber, 2000).

For this we need to do both inner and outer work. We need periods when we withdraw within ourselves to do inner work and to tap the wellsprings of insight and creativity that lie within us. Then we need periods of going out into the world to act in service. This is what Arnold Toynbee called “the cycle of withdrawal and return” and for this there are many metaphors.

In the West, the classic metaphor is Plato’s cave. Here the person escapes from the cave into the light and sees the Good, but then feels impelled to return to the collective darkness of the cave in order to help, heal, and teach others. In Christianity, this final stage is called “fruitfulness of the soul.” The soul that experiences the divine marriage then separates once again in order to help those who have not yet tasted this marriage. Zen portrays this sequence graphically and beautifully in the Ten Ox Herding Pictures, while Joseph Campbell described this process as the hero’s return.

In summary, we go into ourselves to go more effectively out into the world, and we go out into the world in order to go deeper into ourselves through the practice of karma yoga and awakening service. And we keep repeating this cycle until we realize that we and the world are one.

Introduction to Karma Yoga

Anyone who is deeply committed to contemplative practice and to cultivating the qualities it enhances—such as empathy, compassion, clarity and insight, to name only a few—will want to practice as continuously as possible. This means finding a way to use our daily activities and work as part of our practice. Fortunately, such a way is part of the world’s major religious-spiritual traditions, and it is formulated most explicitly in Hinduism as karma yoga.

Hinduism recognizes several distinct kinds of spiritual practice or yoga. Each has its own specific focus, and each is appropriate for a particular kind of person and stage of spiritual life. For example, bhakti yoga focuses on love and devotion, raja yoga on mind training, and jnana yoga on discernment and wisdom (Feuerstein, 1996).

However, karma yoga focuses on the activities and duties of daily life and uses them as the elements of one’s spiritual practice. Its goal is to transform all life into practice, or as the Indian philosopher-sage Aurobindo (1922) put it: “turning of this whole act of living into an uninterrupted yoga” (p. 238).

Karma yoga therefore allows an unbroken continuity of practice, and continuity is widely esteemed as one of the great goals and virtues of spiritual life. For example, the Koran (Koran 2:83) urges “Be constant in prayer” (Cleary, 1993, p. 9) while Ramakrishna claimed that “what is necessary is to pray without ceasing” (Hixon, 1992, p. 116). Likewise the Christian St. Isaac, the Syrian, regarded constant prayer as “the summit of all virtues” (Harvey, 1998, p. 63), and the great Confucian sage Menicus urged “always work at self-cultivation” (Ivanhoe, 2000, p. 65). Karma yoga provides a way to “always work at self-cultivation” by using daily activities as our contemplative practice.

The Three Classic Components of Karma Yoga

Classic texts on karma yoga such as the Bhagavad Gita, which was probably composed around 200 BCE, emphasize three main components:

At the beginning of any activity offer or dedicate the activity to Brahman (God).
Do your dharma (work) as impeccably as possible.
Simultaneously release attachment to the outcome. As the Bhagavad Gita puts it (Prabhavananda and
Isherwood, 1972, p. 45):

Perform every action sacramentally, And be free from all attachment to results.

This three-fold practice is profound. It combines a transpersonal motive which undercuts egocentric motives, a commitment to impeccability which requires cutting through personal blocks and barriers, and a relinquishment of egocentric attachment to having things turn out as we want them to rather than the way they actually do.

This last step of relinquishing attachment to outcome can also be seen as the practice of acceptance which is a powerful practice in its own right. For example, the Stoic philosopher Epictitus, who lived from around c.55-135 C.E., urged ―Accept things as they are. That way peace is possible‖ (Epictetus, 1995, p. 15).

Usually, when we work impeccably for a goal we become attached to the outcome. However, combining impeccability and nonattachment makes karma yoga a knife edge practice which cuts away egocentric motives.

Classic texts such as the Bhagavad Gita are profound and inspiring. However, they are also somewhat vague regarding the specifics of karma yoga, and how exactly one approaches daily life so as to most effectively use all activities as elements of one’s contemplative practice.

After years of exploration and experimentation, I have found it helpful to use the following ten steps.

The 10 Steps of Karma Yoga

Stop before beginning any major activity. Take a moment to stop and breathe. This allows you to become present and to recall your purpose.
Offer the activity to God or to a Higher Power or Source as you understand this.
Choose an intention. The intention we choose for an action determines the meaning it has for us and the results it gives us. We can do the same activity, such as our job, primarily for our own benefit, or for the welfare and awakening of all those with whom we interact. While the activity may be the same, the psychological and spiritual impact on us—and probably those around us—will be very different.One can make sense of this in terms of Maslow’s (1971) hierarchy of needs. As a general principle, a higher order motive – such as self-actualization, self-transcendence, or selfless service – brings its specific benefits plus the benefits of lower order goals as well. For example, if you only aim for lower order motives such as survival and physical comfort, that’s probably all you will get. However, if you also aim for self- actualization, then you will need to include the appropriate satisfaction of lower order needs as well.This is not only good psychology but also good theology. As Jesus said, ―seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness, and all these things shall be added onto you‖ (Mathew 6:33).I find it helpful to inquire at the beginning of major activities, “What is this for?” Or “why am I doing this?” One of the most profound and encompassing answers is the Buddhist Bodhisattva aspiration which seeks to use all activities for the welfare and awakening of all beings, including oneself.
Do the activity as impeccably as you can. Here the goal is to hold to your intention and to express it as impeccably as you can.
Be mindful. Bring as much awareness to the activity as you can, observing, for example, your actions, the environment, your motivation and mental state.
Explore and work with any reactions that arise. These might range from blocks and resistance to pride and joy. It’s especially helpful to be aware of any reactivity to how your activity is turning out, so pay particular attention to emotions which indicate attachment to a specific outcome. These emotions can span a spectrum from delight and pride if things are proceeding as you hoped, to anxiety, anger, disappointment, and hopelessness if they aren’t. All these emotions can be welcomed as feedback signals pointing to an attachment that would be better released (Walsh, 1999; Walsh and Vaughan, 1993).
Release attachment to the outcome. Whenever you notice emotional reactivity indicating an attachment, that’s a feedback signal to attempt to let it go.
Stop again at the end of the activity.
Reflect and learn. Take time to reflect on the activity and your experience and see what you can learn. For example, what
can you learn about doing this activity effectively, about yourself, your mind, and your attachments?
Offer the benefits. Complete the activity by offering its benefit to all others for their welfare and awakening. It seems paradoxical to try to work impeccably and accrue spiritual benefits, and then attempt to give them away. But this final phase of the practice is based on an understanding of the way the mind works and it is crucial to recognize that what we intend for others, we tend to experience ourselves. For example, if we receive benefits such as a sense of satisfaction and wellbeing from karma yoga and intend to offer those benefits to others, these same qualities are then strengthened in our own minds. This is a beautiful example of the principle that within the mind, to give is to receive.

Awakening Service

“A [person] who finds benevolence attractive cannot be surpassed.”Confucius (Lau, 1979, p. 73)

Classic karma yoga does not explicitly aim at the service of others. However, it can easily be transformed into a practice of awakening service or spiritual service by two simple steps (Three and Ten) in the above list.

Step 3: Choose as your intention to use your activities, not only for your own actualization and awakening, but also as a way to serve and awaken others. This service can take many forms, especially to help, heal, teach, and awaken.

Step 10: At the completion of any activity offer the benefits for the welfare and awakening of all.

When an action is done as both karma yoga and as service it becomes what I call awakening service or spiritual service because it combines spiritual practice and service while aiming at awakening and actualizing both oneself and others (Walsh, 1999).

References

Aurobindo. (1922). Essays on the Gita. Pondicherry, India: Sri Aurobindo Ashram Trust.

Cleary, T. (Trans.). (1993). The essential Koran. San Francisco, CA, Harper San Francisco.

Elgin, D. (2013). Great transition stories for becoming a global eco-civilization. Retrieved from:
www.integralworld.net/elgin1.html.

Epictetus. (1995). The art of living. (S. Lebell, Trans.). San Francisco, Harper San Francisco.

Feuerstein, G. (1996). The Shambhala guide to Yoga. Boston, MA: Shambhala.

Harvey, A. (Ed.). (1998). Teachings of the Christian mystics. Boston: Shambhala.

Hixon, L. (Trans.). (1992). Great swan: Meetings with Ramakrishna. Boston, Shambhala.

Ivanhoe, P. (2000). Confucian moral self-cultivation (2nd ed.). Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett.

Lau, D. T. (Trans.). (1979). Confucius: The analects. New York, Penguin Books.

Maslow, A. (1971). The farther reaches of human nature. New York: Viking.

Prabhavananda, S., & Isherwood, C. (Trans.). (1972). The song of God: Bhagavad Gita (3rd ed.). Hollywood, Vedanta Society.

Walsh, R. (1999). Essential spirituality: The seven central practices. New York: Wiley & Sons.

Walsh, R., & Vaughan, F. (1993). The art of transcendence. Journal of Transpersonal Psychology, 25, 1-9.

Wilber, K. (2000). A theory of everything. Boston: Shambhala.

About the Author

Roger Walsh

Roger Walsh, M.D., Ph.D., has spent nearly a quarter century researching and practicing in the world's great spiritual traditions. His critically acclaimed book, Essential Spirituality, is a summary of that wisdom, outlining the seven spiritual practices common to the world's major religions.

Roger Walsh graduated with first-class honors from the University of Queensland with degrees in psychology, physiology, neuroscience, and medicine, while he worked as a circus acrobat and held world records in high diving and the trampoline. He went to Stanford University as a Fulbright scholar and passed licensing exams in medicine, psychology, and psychiatry before moving to the University of California at Irvine where he is currently professor of psychiatry, philosophy, and anthropology. His initial research and writings were in the area of neuroscience and received multiple national and international awards.

Initially extremely skeptical of all things religious and spiritual, he found his attitudes challenged and changed after he tried meditation for himself. He began to research meditation and related areas and to write extensively on topics such as spirituality and psychological well-being. His text on meditation received the "Outstanding Academic Book of 1984" Award, while his book, Paths Beyond Ego was a "Transformational Books" finalist and was listed among Common Boundary's "One Hundred Most Influential Psycho-spiritual Books of the Century". All told, his writings and research have received over twenty national and international awards, while his teaching has received one national award and he has been six times voted "Outstanding Teacher of the Year" by students at the University of California.

INTEGRAL LIFE PRACTICE

Cultivating Wisdom

March 6, 2017

Cultivating Wisdom

In these chaotic times, how do you cultivate the wisdom to move forward? This ILP module offers distillations of the world’s accumulated wisdom—ancient and modern, religious and scientific, philosophical and psychological. It is a unique resource that brings together our collective understanding of wisdom and the ways to develop it.

CONVERSATION

Searching for Wisdom in the 21st Century

April 25, 2016

Searching for Wisdom in the 21st Century

Climate change, wealth inequality, ideological polarization, terrorism, religious radicalization — these are some of the truly wicked problems of the world. And none of our most pressing global challenges can be navigated or overcome without a momentous leap of collective wisdom, as well as a commensurate increase in our ability to recognize and leverage that wisdom. But what exactly is this wisdom that so many of us are searching for? Where can we find it? How do we cultivate it in our own lives and make it available to more people?

BOOK

Essential Spirituality: The 7 Central Practices to Awaken Heart and Mind

Based on over twenty years of research and spiritual practice, this is a groundbreaking and life-changing book. In his decades of study, Dr. Roger Walsh has discovered that each of the great spiritual traditions has both a common goal and seven common practices to reach that goal: recognizing the sacred and divine that exist both within and around us. Filled with stories, exercises, meditations, myths, prayers, and practical advice, Essential Spirituality shows how you can integrate these seven principles into one truly rewarding way of life in which kindness, love, joy, peace, vision, wisdom, and generosity become an ever-growing part of everything you do.