The Rise of the Cosmopolitan: Four Steps to Build a Better Democracy

Jack CrittendenAudio, Cognitive, Conversations, Ethical, Perspectives, Politics, Premium, What is a more hopeful future for civilization? Leave a Comment

In this episode 15 chapters

  1. Greater Depth, Less Span

    Ken introduces Jack's book and argues that global problems need a felt cosmopolitan identity.

  2. Training Perspective-Taking

    Ken presents Jack's four-phase democratic dialogue as training in taking others' perspectives, the engine of development.

  3. The Problem of Imposition

    Ken asks how higher-stage practices can be justified for a population mostly not at those stages, and separates dominator hierarchies from growth hierarchies.

  4. What the Fundamentalist Wants

    Jack argues that people at ethnocentric stages still want the good life and will join dialogue when an issue matters to them.

  5. Wise Ones and Safeguards

    Jack rejects a panel of dialectical experts, pointing out that the enlightened founders wrote slavery into the Constitution.

  6. Four Phases, Psychologically

    Ken walks through the four phases of democratic dialogue and ties them to eros and the extra perspective each stage adds.

  7. Waking Up and Growing Up

    Starting from Francis Collins and the frozen waterfalls, Ken explains how separate lines of development can lag behind cognition.

  8. Moral Rightness and Judges

    Ken and Jack trace how moral rightness has emerged stage by stage through deliberative bodies.

  9. Stations of Life

    Ken argues that developmental stages become stations of life that deserve representation within moral limits.

  10. Integrals in the Closet

    Integral thinkers hide their altitude in green or orange settings, and Ken names about 10% of the population as the tipping point for a major cultural shift.

  11. Storytelling and Mirroring

    A closer look at phase one, judgment-free storytelling that builds trust, and phase two, mapping perspectives and mirroring them back so everyone feels heard.

  12. Integral Christianity

    Ken points to new integral Christianity books and Unity Church's adoption of AQAL as signs that eros can carry fundamentalists toward world-centric views.

  13. Bubbling Up from the Grassroots

    Jack expects implementation to come from the bottom up, through citizen juries, deliberation polls, workplace democracy and democratic schools.

  14. Why Fundamentalism Won't Budge

    The reason-giving phase pushes people to justify boilerplate beliefs, though some can't yet take another's perspective at all.

  15. An Identity as Wide as the World

    Ken covers phase four, finding a common good in a wider context, and sums up the book's thesis: only a felt shift in identity lets suffering anywhere be felt everywhere.

Longtime friends and colleagues Jack Crittenden and Ken Wilber explore a higher-order thought process known as dialectical dialogue, a powerful tool to help bridge the enormous gulf that exists between the many conflicting and entrenched perspectives, values, and ideologies found in modern politics.

Climate change, wealth inequality, political polarization, war and terrorism—these are just some of the greatest (and most argued) problems of the 21st century. These are truly global problems, which can only be addressed from a global perspective. Anything less will only make them worse.

However, this global perspective is itself the product of psychological growth and development over a person’s lifetime, growing through ego-centric (“me”), ethnocentric (“us”), and world-centric (“all of us”) stages of development.

Meanwhile, something like 70% of the planet remains at an ethnocentric, pre-rational, “us vs. them” stage of consciousness (or lower), resulting in all flavors of nationalism, religious fundamentalism, racism, absolutism, etc.

In other words, the majority of the people in the world are simply not equipped to solve the greatest problems of our time, making it all but impossible for the imagination, innovation, and political will we so profoundly need to find any kind of traction.

So, underpinning all of these enormously complex problems is an even more difficult problem: how to accelerate people’s growth through these stages of psychological maturity, so that more of us are able to even see the world’s big problems, let alone try to solve them.

Fortunately, there do seem to be a handful of approaches that can help facilitate growth and development to higher orders of reason and problem solving. One is meditation, a 1st-person approach that, according to researchers like Robert Kegan, has proven to be very effective in helping people transform at an accelerated rate.

And now, thanks to Jack Crittenden, we have another approach that looks just as promising: a 2nd-person approach known as dialectical dialogue—a higher-order process that “transcends but embraces and integrates difference and ambiguity. It permits those using it to expand their perspectives, their worldviews, and even their identities to cosmopolitan or worldwide proportions.” Jack explores this approach in his recent book, Wide as the World: Cosmopolitan Identity, Integral Politics, and Democratic Dialogue.

Using the dialectical dialogue process, we may be able to improve our political and socio-economic systems in such a way that allows people to be whoever they are, at whatever stage of development they find themselves, while also encouraging growth to the higher stages of psychological development. As the book description says, “when built in as part of the structures of democratic dialogue, dialectical thinking can help elected officials and ordinary citizens alike, from local meetings to global institutions, address and solve our most vexing problems.”

Written by Corey W. deVos
Image: Land of Plenty by Bo Bartlett [view gallery]

Become a member to access the full episode

Start building your big picture mind & support the global emergence of Integral consciousness

“Integral Life is the most important and globally-relevant platform for the leading edge of Integral consciousness evolution”

– Eugene P.

Learn about our membership

About Jack Crittenden

In 1976 Jack Crittenden and Ken Wilber started ReVision, a journal of knowledge and consciousness. Several decades later Jack, as a founding member, helped Ken start the Integral Institute, and he currently serves on its Board of Directors. In between Jack earned a doctorate from Oxford University in political theory, which he has been teaching for over 25 years at Arizona State University.

About Ken Wilber

Ken Wilber is a preeminent scholar of the Integral stage of human development. He is an internationally acknowledged leader, founder of Integral Institute, and co-founder of Integral Life. Ken is the originator of arguably the first truly comprehensive or integrative world philosophy, aptly named “Integral Theory”.

Leave a Comment