The Wonderful (But Flawed) Ideals of DEI

Keith Martin-Smith September 13, 2024Audio, Cognitive, Deep Transformation, Ethical, Free, Moral, Politics, Self-Identity, World Affairs

““Everybody cares… they just care about different things. Consensus and change come from being willing to listen to what people care about and finding space to honor that.””Keith Martin-Smith

Award-winning author, Zen priest and teacher, Kung Fu master, and professional advisor and trainer, Keith Martin-Smith, took a good look at the diversity, equity, and inclusion movement when he began to notice the damage it was causing people he knew under the guise of progress, or equity. Putting his keen mind to the task, Keith identified seven key areas where the DEI movement goes markedly astray from the values it aspires to. Coming from an integral understanding, Keith does more than simply point out where the movement has backfired. We learn that postmodern thinking is how we became aware of the “subtle soup of racism [and bias] in the cultural field itself”—beyond the concrete, obvious social injustices that activists fought in the 20th century. This more subtle field of bias is responsible for the inequalities we see in society today, which is what the DEI movement would like to tear down. But the ways in which DEI acts to make this happen, ironically, are characterized by exactly the things that DEI is against: intolerance, inequity, undiversity, tribalism, and anti-liberalism.

In his wise, articulate, and gracious way, Keith makes sense of why the diversity, equity, and inclusion movement has become a political flashpoint, raising the hackles of not only rightwing conservatives but also liberal progressives. Sympathetic to the values of DEI, Keith is all about helping to create a more diverse, equitable, and inclusive movement. When asked how the values of DEI could be fulfilled to make it the harmonious, effective, correcting movement it aspires to be, Keith responded, “with conversations like this, for one thing,” adding, “we need to realize that everyone has a portion of truth—we just need to connect everyone’s portion of truth with their heart.”

Recorded June 6, 2024.

Topics & Timestamps: Part 1

Introducing award-winning author, professional advisor & trainer, martial arts master, Zen priest & teacher Keith Martin-Smith (01:12)
How Keith came to articulate what has gone wrong with the diversity, equity & inclusion movement (01:49)
The divisiveness of DEI and the need to bring in an integral understanding (06:22)
The difference between concrete, overt injustices and systemic injustice (08:27)
The subtle soup of racism in the cultural field that we have become aware of in the postmodern period (11:19)
All the punches at DEI are being thrown from an early rational or prerational worldview (15:26)
What are the seven deadly sins of DEI? (18:15)
DEI’s simplistic view of privilege, considering race, sex & gender, but not class, education & family of origin (19:00)
What are healthy responses to having been given privilege (as opposed to shame and guilt)? (23:37)
DEI proponents lecturing us about privilege don’t talk about their own privilege (26:50)
The effect of neglecting class in DEI’s reductionist view of privilege (29:56)
The problematic (undiverse) way the DEI movement treats diversity (34:31)
Concrete racism versus subtle racism/microaggressions (37:49)
Because Asians are doing so well, they are excluded from the diversity discussion (39:56)
Intolerant tolerance and the why the 2017 women’s march movement fell apart (41:49)
Robin diAngelo, white fragility, systemic internalized racism (43:49)
Dismissing views you don’t agree with (46:57)
Holding privilege with humility and the importance of genuinely listening (49:05)
The purity test requiring people to toe the DEI party line (50:11)

Topics & Timestamps: Part 2

DEI’s overemphasis on oppression and power: how it started (00:50)
Critical race theory’s metaview is that the world operates on principles of power and oppression (01:57)
The single cause fallacy (02:59)
Drawing the wrong conclusions: Kenyans and marathons, women and STEM fields (04:10)
Male dominance in sports caused by bias rather than biology? (12:03)
The wage gap between men and women and significant difference it makes to control for factors (18:51)
Why men outearn women at Uber: subtle differences in the way men and women behave (27:39)
IQ and how men dominate the extremes of the Bell Curve (29:34)
Fairness demands that everyone is treated the best way possible (34:18)
Brief review of the main DEI flaws covered so far: DEI’s simplistic view of privilege; how DEI’s diversity doesn’t look at diverse mindsets; intolerance of other viewpoints; pushing everything through critical race theory; and how equality of outcomes can be oppressive, unfair, sexist & racist (35:31)
Tribalism: DEI compartmentalizes everyone to a tribalistic identity, with the focus on race and sex (40:05)
How to explain a white supremacist group run by people who are not white: multiracial whiteness (46:00)
The primary goal should be to cultivate relationship rather than projecting a whole history on an individual based on their skin color or sex (49:20)

Topics & Timestamps: Part 3

What is liberalism? (01:18)
The nature of DEI’s anti-liberalism: banning free speech and more (05:08)
White fragility is a non-argument and it’s anti-liberal (09:30)
Another dangerous idea: silence is violence (10:44)
Allowing trial by public opinion (11:41)
Creating a true meritocracy: results from blind auditioning symphony musicians (14:13)
Forced equality of outcome: is forcing 20% of symphony goers to be black a good idea? (15:31)
Going far right and far left, you find they mirror each other (18:32)
The klansmen who turned in their robes after talking to a black man (21:11)
What could be done to fulfill the values of DEI and make it the effective correcting movement it aspires to be? (23:39)
DEI at its best: recognizing the subtle ways in which cognitive bias affects the culture (27:05)
The postmodern/DEI point of view doesn’t see how they are projecting their beliefs onto the culture (29:45)
Microaggressions are real—but DEI proponents conflate microaggressions with macroaggressions (34:46)
Critical race theory is the only explanatory theory in the DEI toolbox (39:33)
Critical theory says power dynamics distort all interactions (44:15)
The presumption of oppression and power is inaccurate from a biological standpoint (50:17)
Partial truths are worth honoring (53:14)
Everybody cares: finding space to honor that (56:09)
What can we do to turn things around? (59:34)
The difference between dignity and respect (01:01:10)

Podcast produced by Vanessa Santos

Presented by iAwake Technologies’ innovative, sound-tech infused Stealing Flow.

Stealing Flow is a 25-minute brainwave entrainment audio track for a full-spectrum, whole-brain workout ideal to listen to before beginning your day’s work, or as a morning meditation.

Check out the free sample:

Click here to hear more!

About the Deep Transformation series

Embark on a sonic journey that sponsors deep relaxation, enhanced focus, and a greater sense of being in the moment. The melodious flavors and subtle guidance of the tracks “Borealis” and “Polaris” will call you back into their comfort and mystique, again and again.

Increase creativity and resourceful states
Lift and stabilize mood
Experience enhanced focus and expanded flow of awareness

Click here to learn more about Deep Transformation!

Previous Episodes of Deep Transformation

The Mysterious World of Shamanism

Roger Walsh

Roger Walsh provides us with a brilliant, big picture perspective, pointing out that at the heart of shamanism (and every great world tradition) are psychospiritual technologies—actual practices—that lead us to the doorway of the Great Mystery, and that service is the culmination of each tradition, both as a means to and an expression of one’s realization.

Democracy in Decline? The Supreme Court and the Threat to Public Morality

Mark Fischler

How did the democratic process and the values it represents — equality and liberty for all — come to be teetering on the brink? Mark illuminates the fact that the Constitution is not a set-in-stone document, but eminently open to interpretation, and explains that its interpretation is a direct reflection of the worldviews of the Supreme Court justices. In fact, the whole process of democracy needs to be aligned with a certain level of development in order to deliver...

Ken Wilber’s Map of Everything

Brad Reynolds

Brad Reynolds gives us a beautiful distillation of Ken Wilber’s work, starting from the beginning and spanning decades. Not only does Brad elegantly relate the major themes of Ken’s work, he also makes clear the value of Ken’s contributions—the way this knowledge can be understood and applied to literally expand our notion of reality and evolve our consciousness

The Psychology of Climate Change

Gail Hochachka

Climate change researcher, sustainable development expert, and activist Gail Hochachka works on the front lines of climate change research, asking—and answering—questions like: How does the way we make meaning, at all our different stages of development, relate to the ways we act on climate change? How can we foster more engagement with climate change? Is climate action scalable? And how are we going to show up for the people who are facing the greatest impacts?

Bringing Soul and Integrity to American Politics

Marianne Williamson

More than a political talk, Marianne reveals a psychological and spiritual portrait of the United States, referencing the brilliant vision of our founding fathers, Martin Luther King’s goal of Beloved Community, and telling a stirring story of the way Abraham Lincoln’s second inauguration reflects the high morality of the populace at that time.

Deepening Our Explorations of Reality

Bruce Alderman

Bruce Alderman, poet, mystic, and spiritual explorer, is also an integral scholar and pioneer of the emerging field of metatheory, looking at how to put our disparate fields of information—spiritual, psychological, philosophical, environmental, scientific—together and integrate them into a useful whole.

Buddhas in Blue: Enlightened Ways to Make Policing Work For Everyone

Ryan Johansen

In this moving, illuminating, and impassioned discussion, retired Police Lt. Chris Orrey and San Bruno Police Chief Ryan Johansen open our eyes as to the realities of policing in today’s world and offer solutions as to how the entire institution of police work could be transformed to become more effective and sustainable, both for police officers and for the communities they serve.

The Essence of Awakening: Who Are We Really?

Lama Surya Das

Lama Surya Das, beloved meditation teacher, scholar, pioneer of bringing Tibetan Buddhism to the West, and author of the bestseller Awakening the Buddha Within among many more, shares bright gems of wisdom from his extensive experience practicing Dzogchen, his long immersion in meditation retreats, and studying in person with the great spiritual teachers of Asia.

Building a Just World: How Our Laws Express Our Collective Values

Mark Fischler

Constitutional law expert and criminal justice professor Mark Fischler has a thirst for justice and a gift for teaching. With cogency and passion, Mark explains that law is not the absolute that we perhaps thought, but an ever changing reflection of the values we hold as a society. Law is a developmental process, and will benefit from our own dedication to inner moral development.

The Enneagram as a Spiritual Tool

Leslie Hershberger

Enneagram expert, teacher, master facilitator, and transformational coach Leslie Hershberger leads us into the world of the Enneagram, painting a broader, deeper picture of the Enneagram and its uses as a psycho-spiritual tool than is commonly understood.

From Race to Culture to Kosmos

Greg Thomas

Join cultural analyst and co-founder of the Jazz Leadership Project, Greg Thomas, as he explores the transformative power of culture, using his knowledge of jazz and blues as a conduit to greater understanding and connection. Greg tackles layered issues of race through a systemic lens, suggesting a shift from racial to cultural worldview, offering an enlightening dialogue filled with anecdotes from music history and a rich exploration of how shared cultural experiences can dissolve boundaries and unite us all.

Grappling with the Metacrisis

Sean Esbjörn-Hargens

In this dialogue, the world of metatheories comes alive with urgent, purposeful meaning, because as Sean and Nick point out, integrative metatheories like Ken Wilber’s integral theory and Roy Bhaskar’s critical realism are the only tools that provide a useful framework for us to talk about and confront the vast web of interrelated and wicked problems we face on every level at this time.

Illuminating the Integral Vision: A Metatheory for Understanding Self, Life, and the World

Corey deVos

Corey gives a terrifically lucid explanation of what the term Integral encompasses: a stage of psychological development, a description of Ken Wilber’s life’s work, and a comprehensive map that comes alive for people, guiding their way and making sense out of enormously complex issues. Corey also describes Integral as a gateway between two massive phases in human history — the “adolescent” phase of collective development now starting to fall behind us, and an integrated phase quite possibly ahead.

The Edge of the Future: Education, Civilization, and the Metacrisis

Zach Stein

Educator, author, philosopher, and futurist Zachary Stein gives a startling account of the effects the digital age already has on education and where this is headed. Zak sees education in a deeply philosophical sense as fundamental to the sustainability of our civilization, with implications for each component of the metacrisis. Who will be driving the technology stack that actually leads to a viable civilization? Can we maintain our psychological sovereignty in a sea of digital propaganda and know the truth?

The Human Potential Movement: Then and Now

Mike Murphy

Michael Murphy, author, co-founder of the world-famous Esalen Institute, and pioneer of the Human Potential Movement starting in the 60s, relates a wealth of intimate experience, knowledge, and wisdom covering his decades of living at the leading edge of transformative practice and the realization of human potential.

Nature as Teacher: Finding Beauty, Wisdom, and Self in Everything

Susanne Cook-Greuter

Adult psychology pioneer and ego development expert Susanne Cook-Greuter introduces us to her favorite wisdom teacher: Nature. Susanne explains how Integral Theory’s 3-2-1 Process can be practiced with elements in nature to gain greater insight into the teachings of nature—evolution, cycles of life and death, the transience of life, the beauty that is everywhere—and to experience oneness with all.

Awakening Joy: Life Skills for Living, Loving, and Serving Life to the Full

James Baraz

James’ teachings take us deeply into states like gratitude and compassionate presence, to where we can focus our attention on how it feels to feel good somatically, thereby creating new neural pathways that strengthen awareness and aliveness. James has witnessed a lot of people learn to love themselves and turn their lives around as a result of this teaching.

Nonduality (And Beyond)

A. H. Almaas

A.H. Almaas (Hameed Ali), renowned author and co-creator of the Diamond Approach, describes his own process of inquiry and some of what he has come to discover in his lifelong pursuit to understand the nature of reality and know the truth.

The Source and Heart of Judaism and the Great Religions

Zvi Ish-Shalom

In this remarkable conversation, Zvi describes how he found ways to map and interpret his own profound mystical experiences, how the teachings arise from the ground of being, about how they might become accessible to us all, regardless of religion or spiritual tradition, and how they are especially relevant for young people today, seeking to find a structure for their spiritual journey.

Vertical Development’s Many Gifts

Beena Sharma

Beena Sharma, president of the Vertical Development Academy (VeDA), gives a beautifully cogent explanation of the 8-stage, full spectrum model of adult psychological development, Vertical Development — illuminating us not only to the characteristics of each stage of development, but the implications and ramifications of each stage, the process of human development as a whole, and how this model can help us face our current metacrisis.

The Remarkable Practice of Dream Yoga

Andrew Holecek

Lucid dreaming expert, author, “curiouist,” and integralist Andrew Holecek explains how lucid dreaming opens the door to a greatly expanded understanding of our minds, our perception of reality, and human potential altogether.

Become a member today to watch this video presentation and support the global emergence of Integral consciousness

About Keith Martin-Smith

Keith Martin-Smith is an award-winning author, writing coach, and Zen priest. He is passionate about human connection, creativity, and evolution. His books include "The Mysterious Divination of Tea Leaves", "A Heart Blown Open", and "The Heart of Zen". His most recent book is his first novel, "Only Everything", a novel that explores the promise and the pain of following an artist's path.

About Roger Walsh

Roger Walsh, M.D., Ph.D., has spent nearly a quarter century researching and practicing in the world's great spiritual traditions. His critically acclaimed book, Essential Spirituality, is a summary of that wisdom, outlining the seven spiritual practices common to the world's major religions.

About John Dupuy

John Dupuy is co-founder and CEO of iAwake Technologies, a company that creates cutting-edge, high-tech brainwave entrainment soundtracks that support the healing of emotional/shadow issues, deepen meditation, mental focus, creativity, and flow states, and enhance a daily integral transformative practice. John has been working personally and professionally with brainwave entrainment technology since 2004, and travels internationally to teach and inspire on the subjects of Integral Transformative Practice and Integral Recovery®. John is also the author of Integral Recovery: A Revolutionary Approach to the Treatment of Alcoholism and Addiction (SUNY Press, 2013), winner of the 2013 USA Best Book Award, and co-host of the popular Journey of Integral Recovery podcast. John also hosts the online series Spiritual Tech Talks 2.0, in which he converses with leaders, pioneers, and inventors on the current wave of emerging spiritual technologies.