The Major and Minor Scales of Integral Politics

Ken Wilber Cognitive, Ethical, Perspectives, Politics, The Ken Show, Values, Video, What is a more hopeful future for civilization?, Worldviews 3 Comments

Log in to see the full 3.5 hour episode.

Ken Wilber and Corey deVos take an in-depth look at the “major and minor scales” of integral politics — an inventory of the most critical elements, polarities, and patterns of self-organization that are at play within all of the major political systems across the world, from the rise of civilization to today.

Major Scales
#1: Internal/External
#2: Individual/Collective
#3: Transformation/Translation (progressive/conservative)
#4: Altitude (levels and lines)

Minor Scales
#1: Lines (e.g. “walk” and “talk”)
#2: Agency/Communion
#3: Progression/Regression
#4: Stage/Stations
#5: Regulator (governing system)
Bonus: Ken’s Utopia

FREE EBOOK

These major and minor scales were first presented in Ken’s eBook, Integral Politics: Its Essential Ingredients, available to download for free.

Download Your Free eBook

Each of these major and minor scales exert their influence at all times, but one or two of them often come to the forefront during any given election. The media usually doesn’t know what to do with these multiple drives and polarities, because they are usually locked into the oversimplified “left versus right” frame, and anything resembling “depth” or “nuance” becomes lost in the noise of identity politics, paid propaganda, and true-but-partial partisanship.

We live at a time when an overabundance of low-fidelity information results in a radical oversimplification of our own views, values, and deeply-held political narratives, reducing the incredibly complex machinery of our political system into a winner-take-all gladiatorial contest between opposing tribes and factions. It’s become politics-as-sport, where allegiance to one’s team outweighs our allegiance to a vibrant and fully functioning society. The political pendulum becomes a partisan wrecking ball, where each side is only concerned with demolishing and dismantling the successes of the other.

This discussion, along with Ken’s eBook, will help you bring more discernment and sophistication to your own political views, as well as to those around you. You will gain a far more comprehensive understanding of the issues, policies, and candidates that affect your life, allowing you to more easily identify and include the important partial truths within each of our major political parties and movements. It will also help you to escape the ethnocentric gravity pulling you to identify exclusively with only one side of the street or the other, and avoid the lazy cynicism of false equivalence and simplistic “both sides are the same” narratives.

“Feeling these dimensions and wishing to place them into political action is what generates a political theoria and praxis. However, consciously or unconsciously focusing on only a few of its elements—just a few quadrants to the exclusion of others, or just one level to the exclusion of others, etc.—generates a partial politics, exclusionary and brutalizing in its nature and means.”
Ken Wilber, Integral Politics: Its Essential Ingredients

Major Scale #1: Internal/External


Become a supporting member to watch the full conversation

Every member of Integral Life gets access to the perspectives library (15+ years of content) and a constantly evolving Integral Life Practice platform. Learn how to apply Integrative metatheory both to the most complex global issues and your everyday life & transform yourself in order to thrive in a rapidly-evolving world of the 21st century!

Get Full Access For $1 (30 days)* Or get an annual subscription ($99, 40% off) * Trial price for the first 30 days, then $15/month. Cancel or switch plans in 2 minutes at any time.

“If we are to pick one of the three axes that has most often and consistently been identified with the Left/Right axis, it is the internalist/externalist one. Virtually all schools of the Left—including new Left and old Left and everything in between— believe in some form of external causation of human suffering. Whatever happens to you, it is not your fault! It is society’s fault. How to cure that is another thing. But the cause is clear to the Left: it is bad nurture, not bad nature, that causes human suffering. Likewise, both old and new Right both believe in the fundamentally interior cause of human suffering, from family values to the work ethic, or lack thereof. Thus, if we have to pick only one, we say that the Left is externalist and the Right is internalist.” —Ken Wilber

Major Scale #2: Individual/Collective


“[An Integral approach to politics] therefore suggests that neither individual nor collective is primary; there is simply an occasion, and that occasion has both individual and social dimensions, both of which are equiprimordial, neither of which can be reduced to the other or elevated above the other. Therefore, any political theory that wishes to accord with the actual architecture of reality—or simply the nature of present experience— needs to harmoniously balance both individual and collective, private autonomy and public autonomy, subjective and intersubjective, and not ignore either of those, or try to reduce it to the other or use it to trump the other.” —Ken Wilber

Major scale #3: Transformation/Translation (progressive/conservative)

Become a member to watch

“A healthy holon is faced with two basic choices: upward transformation, driven by Eros, or healthy translation, driven by Agape. Hence, the transformation/translation axis in healthy practice is essentially the same as the progressive/conservative axis, and, when used in that sense, we call both of them the third major axis.” —Ken Wilber

Major Scale #4: Altitude (levels and lines)

Become a member to watch

“Each holon possesses those three major axes (internalist/externalist, individualist/collectivist, progressive/conservative), but, as always, all of those exist only at a particular altitude, so it is necessary to specify the altitude of any political idea or movement, in both its theoria and its praxis. What level does it spring from? What level does it serve? This is the levels scale (#4, or the fourth and last major scale we use). This scale is very important, because the most basic values of a political movement (not its only values, just its most fundamental values) will be set by its altitude—after all, one can be amber progressive, orange progressive, green progressive, turquoise progressive, etc. Or one can be amber conservative, orange conservative, green conservative, etc. Likewise, one can be amber collectivist, orange collectivist, green collectivist, etc. Or amber externalist, orange externalist, green externalist, and so on. Being a collectivist or a conservative or a progressive, and so forth, usually pales in significance to its altitude, although all of them are important and necessary for an Integral indexing.” —Ken Wilber

Minor Scale #1: Lines (e.g. “walk” and “talk”)

Become a member to watch

“For a finer analysis of altitude, we look not just at the general level of a political theory or movement, but what developmental levels in what developmental lines? In particular, what level does it talk (the cognitive line)? And what level does it walk (the self line, or the center of gravity, COG)? And in both of those lines, what level does it come from, and what level of constituency does it actually address—i.e., what is not only the theorist’s but the masses’ center of gravity?” —Ken Wilber

Minor Scale #2: Agency/Communion

Become a member to watch

“Translation (i.e. the third major scale) itself can emphasize agency or communion, both of which fall under the Agape drive at any given level, which is the drive to conserve and preserve that level (and its lower-level constituents) using healthy translation, or agency-and-communion at that level.” —Ken Wilber

Minor Scale #3: Progression/Regression

Become a member to watch

“If a holon actually changes levels (and doesn’t just reach up or reach down—but moves up or moves down), that transformative change can be either progressive or regressive in character. Normal progression, or upward transformation, is driven by healthy Eros (unhealthy Eros is repression, or Phobos, i.e., driven essentially by fear), while regression, or downward movement, is driven by unhealthy Agape, or Thanatos (i.e., the dissolution/death drive), so the Eros/Thanatos opposition gives us the minor scale known as the progression/regression scale).” —Ken Wilber

Minor Scale #4: Stage/Stations

Become a member to watch

“How many levels of consciousness does a political theory authentically address? It does no good to say that I am taking the whole Spectrum into account if I cannot tell you exactly how to let red be red and amber be amber and orange be orange and green be green—and still govern from turquoise. Without cracking that nut, there is no Integral. As noted, adults will stop their development at any number of stages—there will always be red adults and green adults and indigo adults—and that is their right. At any point in history, the political ideal is to let each stage be itself, and govern from the highest reasonably available at any given time.” —Ken Wilber

Minor Scale #5: Regulator (governing system)

Become a member to watch

“Another minor scale that is sometimes important and can be included is the role of the Governor or Regulator, which every social holon possesses (this scale runs from nonexistent anarchist to minimalist Guardian to maximalist State; this is the Regulator scale, and we usually present it as minimalist/maximalist Regulator). This scale often overlaps, but is nonetheless distinct from, the (#2) individualist/collectivist axis (i.e., while it is true that many collectivists are State interventionists, some collectivists wish to achieve collectivism via means other than State intervention, such as naturalism or local communitarianism). Although minimalist/maximalist is often enfolded in the individualist/collectivist axis because of their frequent overlap, this is nonetheless an independent variable.” —Ken Wilber

BONUS: Ken’s Utopia

Become a member to watch

We hope you enjoyed this episode of The Ken Show! Let us know what you think in the comments below, and also be sure to let us know if you have any questions for future episodes!


FREE EBOOK

These major and minor scales were first presented in Ken’s eBook, Integral Politics: Its Essential Ingredients, available to download for free.

Download Your Free eBook

Previous Episodes of The Ken Show

The Science of Subtle Energy
Cognitive Perspectives Science & Technology Spiritual Spirituality The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) Video

The Science of Subtle Energy

In this episode of The Ken Show we take a look at Ken's "Comprehensive Theory of Subtle Energy”, which offers an elegant summary of how these energies might be accounted for by integral metatheory and integrated with our scientific understanding of the universe.
Ken Wilber Goes to High School: Sex, Ecology, Spirituality
Cognitive Free Integral Basics Interpersonal Intrapersonal Perspectives Spiritual Spirituality The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) Video

Ken Wilber Goes to High School: Sex, Ecology, Spirituality

In this very special episode of The Ken Show we are joined by Aissatou Diallo, Zoe Tray, and Noah Delorme, students at Choate Rosemary Hall who have been studying Ken Wilber’s seminal book, Sex, Ecology, Spirituality for their senior year project. Watch as Ken, Aissatou, Zoe, and Noah unpack many of the core insights of SES and discuss the unique value Integral work holds for a new generation of thinkers, leaders, artists, and scholars.
Practice the Wound of Love
Cognitive Defenses Emotional How can I awaken to spiritual wisdom? Interpersonal Intrapersonal Love & Intimacy Perspectives Spiritual The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2)

Practice the Wound of Love

Watch as Ken and Corey explore the ongoing unfoldment of love along the paths of Waking Up, Growing Up, Opening Up, Cleaning Up, and Showing Up. What follows is one of the most powerful, transformative, and touching conversations that Ken Wilber has ever recorded.
Marx, Mysticism, and Mathematics: Navigating Our Epistemic Collapse
Cognitive Integrative Metatheory Media type Perspectives The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) Video What is truth?

Marx, Mysticism, and Mathematics: Navigating Our Epistemic Collapse

In this episode we continue our fascinating discussion about Integral epistemology, taking a look at the important but partial truths of Marxism, how we go about verifying and confirming spiritual experiences, and the involutionary/evolutionary nature of mathematics.
Integral Epistemology
Cognitive Integrative Metatheory Perspectives The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) What is truth?

Integral Epistemology

How do we know stuff? Like all of the great philosophical quandaries, it’s a fundamentally straightforward question that can lead us into an endlessly branching series of chicken-and-egg meditations on the nature of existence (ontology) versus the nature of knowledge (epistemology). In this fascinating episode of The Ken Show, we take a look at a dozen of the most popular schools of epistemological thought — idealism, pragmatism, empiricism, constructivism, etc. — noting their respective contributions and limitations, and how they can all be pulled together into a more Integral epistemology.
Awaken the Eye of Spirit
Cognitive How can I awaken to spiritual wisdom? Integrative Metatheory Perspectives Spiritual Spirituality The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) Video

Awaken the Eye of Spirit

All of us possess three primary modes of perception that we use to disclose reality – the "Eye of Flesh", the "Eye of Mind", and the "Eye of Spirit". Watch as Ken and Corey explore these ideas and the many ways we perceive and interpret spiritual realities.
Integrating Shadow
Cognitive Defenses Emotional How can I feel happy and fulfilled in my life? Integral Basics Integrative Metatheory Intrapersonal Perspectives Psychology The Ken Show The Ken Show (v2) Video

Integrating Shadow

Ken and Corey offer a stunning overview of the psychological shadow. Ken describes several different kinds of shadow, how shadow can show up differently in all four quadrants, and the relationship between shadow, violence, and social transformation.
Coronavirus and a Course in Anti-Fragility
Cognitive Health & Wellness Perspectives The Ken Show Video World Affairs Worldviews

Coronavirus and a Course in Anti-Fragility

Ken and Corey respond to the COVID-19 pandemic by suggesting a far more comprehensive approach to health and healing. Watch as we take a tour through all four quadrants of healthy living — a much-needed guide to integral anti-fragility in the 21st century.
The Four Quadrants: A Guided Tour
Cognitive Integrative Metatheory Perspectives The Ken Show Video What is Integral?

The Four Quadrants: A Guided Tour

Ken and Corey take a in-depth tour through one of Ken’s most well-known contributions to integral philosophy: the Four Quadrants. Watch as Ken shares his personal story about the origins of the Four Quadrant model — the day everything came together — as he weaves 3rd-person theoretical descriptions of the model with his own 1st-person experience and creative process.
Big Time: Integral Historiography and You
Cognitive Editor's Picks History Integrative Metatheory Perspectives The Ken Show Video What is truth?

Big Time: Integral Historiography and You

Ken unpacks his own approach to integral historiography, helping us to better understand our own place in history — and history's place in us.
Integral Social Justice
Cognitive Ethical Gender How should we relate to the social justice movement? Moral Perspectives Politics The Ken Show Values Video World Affairs Worldviews

Integral Social Justice

In this stunning 3 hour discussion, Ken Wilber offers his own views around healthy and unhealthy forms of social justice, praising the healthy and legitimate efforts to enact social justice over the generations while noting how much of today’s broken discourse around social justice is helping to perpetuate multiple forms of injustice.
Wicked Problems: Gun Violence
Cognitive Defenses Editor's Picks Ethical How should we relate to the social justice movement? Perspectives Politics The Ken Show Video World Affairs

Wicked Problems: Gun Violence

In this exclusive series, Ken and Corey take an in-depth look at America’s ongoing struggle with gun violence, using the four quadrants to track many of the most critical and commonly-blamed factors, conditions, and causes that seem to be contributing to this terribly wicked problem.
Kosmos: An Integral Voyage
Cognitive Existential Futurism Perspectives Science & Technology Space-time Spirituality The Ken Show Video Worldviews

Kosmos: An Integral Voyage

Ken Wilber and Corey deVos ponder the evolutionary mysteries of the universe, speculating on how abundant life might be in the kosmos, why we haven’t met any of our galactic neighbors yet, and what might happen if a UFO landed on the White House lawn. It’s a fun conversation — and one that takes its subject matter more seriously than you might expect. Whether you are a true believer of UFO phenomena or an iron-clad skeptic, you don’t want to miss this fascinating and far-reaching exploration.
The Varieties of Integral Spiritual Experience
Cognitive Existential How can I awaken to spiritual wisdom? Integrative Metatheory Intrapersonal Perspectives Spiritual Spirituality The Ken Show Video

The Varieties of Integral Spiritual Experience

Watch as Ken and Corey explore the path of Waking Up — a guided tour through temporary states of consciousness that include everything from emotional states to chemically-induced states to the direct, immediate experience of timeless reality, revealing an infinitely renewable source of energy, resilience, and creative inspiration that rests at the very center of you.
The Many Ways We Grow
Aesthetic Cognitive Defenses Emotional Ethical Existential Gender Integral Basics Integrative Metatheory Interpersonal Intrapersonal Kinesthetic Moral Musical Needs Perspectives Psychology Psychosexual Self-Identity Space-time Spiritual The Ken Show Values Video Volitional What is human development? Worldviews

The Many Ways We Grow

Human development is uneven, which means that we are better at some things than we are at others. Some skills come more naturally to us, and others are more difficult to acquire. Watch as Ken and Corey explore each of these developmental capacities in detail, offering a powerful summary of human potentials, talents, and intelligences — a comprehensive map of the territory of “you” that will help guide your own ongoing growth and development.
Growing Up: A Guided Tour
Aesthetic Cognitive Integrative Metatheory Intrapersonal Perspectives The Ken Show Values Video What is human development? Worldviews

Growing Up: A Guided Tour

In this episode of The Ken Show we explore one of the most central elements of integral metatheory: growing up through multiple stages of developmental maturity. Watch as Ken and Corey offer a guided tour through each of the major stages on the Path of Growing Up — an exploration of your own greatest, deepest potentials — and offer some simple practices to help you actualize those potentials.
On the Front Line of the Culture War — Give Me Some Real Examples, Not Just Theories!
Cognitive Ethical Perspectives Politics The Ken Show Values Video What is a more hopeful future for civilization? Worldviews

On the Front Line of the Culture War — Give Me Some Real Examples, Not Just Theories!

Watch as Ken and Corey offer their views on some of the most controversial policy debates of our time, each of which has become a battle line in our constantly escalating culture wars.
The Baby and the Bathwater: Saving Liberalism
Cognitive Ethical How should we relate to the social justice movement? Perspectives Politics The Ken Show Values Video World Affairs Worldviews

The Baby and the Bathwater: Saving Liberalism

In this episode of The Ken Show we explore five themes near and dear to the liberal heart — tolerance, nonviolence, power, privilege, and gender — celebrating the healthy aspects of each that we want to include in a more integral embrace, while weeding out the unhealthy regressive narratives that most of these have devolved into.
Beyond the Nation-State: Globalism, Plutocracy, and the Integral World Federation
Cognitive Ethical Perspectives Politics The Ken Show Video What is a more hopeful future for civilization? Worldviews

Beyond the Nation-State: Globalism, Plutocracy, and the Integral World Federation

Ken and Corey explore how today’s transnational challenges and realities may be hastening humanity’s eventual growth toward increasingly inclusive and global forms of governance, what government might look like at the level of the global holon, and how we might actually be able to get there from here.
Is Free Will an Illusion?
Art & Creativity Cognitive Existential Integrative Metatheory Perspectives Psychology Spiritual The Ken Show Video Volitional

Is Free Will an Illusion?

In this episode of The Ken Show we explore one of the oldest and, in many ways, most profound and consequential philosophical questions in history: what is the nature of “free will”, and is it ultimately just an illusion?
[/content_band]
Ken Wilber

About Ken Wilber

Ken Wilber is a preeminent scholar of the Integral stage of human development. He is an internationally acknowledged leader, founder of Integral Institute, and co-founder of Integral Life. Ken is the originator of arguably the first truly comprehensive or integrative world philosophy, aptly named “Integral Theory”.

Corey deVos

About Corey deVos

Corey W. deVos is Editor-in-Chief of Integral Life, as well as Managing Editor of KenWilber.com. He has worked for Integral Institute/Integal Life since Spring of 2003, and has been a student of integral theory and practice since 1996. Corey is also a professional woodworker, and many of his artworks can be found in his VisionLogix art gallery.

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for frank frank says:

    In one of the recent Integral LIfe videos on Integral Politics Wilber refers to his use, in Up from Eden (1981), of the terms “internalist” and “externalist” for the two basic political orientations. He adds that a short while after publication of this book Time magazine published a feature article using the same dichotomoy.

    The suggestion here is that he was the first to introduce it and it ended up in a nation-wide publication shortly after he had published it.

    I think I have located the article in the Times archive here, it was published in 1983:

    INTERNALIST, EXTERNALIST

    By GADDIS SMITH - MARCH 27, 1983
    https://www.nytimes.com/1983/03/27/books/internalist-externalist.html

    However, the article seems to use these terms in a totally different context and meaning.

    Wilber’s use of these terms is that externalists see the causes of suffering in the structures of society that oppress; and internatlists see these causes in character and individual effort to improve your lfe. (See Up from Eden , Chapter 19, “Republicans, Democrats and Mystics”)

    This Times article covers the two different types of US foreign policy, and uses “externalist” for those who see the enemy abroad, while “internalists” see the enemy within the US borders.

    Seems to me to be a totally different use of these terms. Especially in this quote, the meaning is completely opposite to Wilber’s intended use:

    The externalists are usually but not always those in power and their supporters.
    Internalists are almost always critics of those in power and of their policies.

    In Wilber’s model, externalists are Democrats, who usualy oppose vested interests and internalists are Republicans, who usually believe in authority and individual effort.

    Is this the correct Times article or is there any other?

Continue the discussion at community.integrallife.com

2 more replies

Participants