How Self-Hatred Can Lead to Self Transformation

Dr. Keith WittCognitive, Defenses, Emotional, How can I feel happy and fulfilled in my life?, Intrapersonal, Psychology, Video, Witt & Wisdom: Live with Dr. Keith Leave a Comment

Become a supporting member to watch the full conversation

Humanity is entering the Transformation Age, a new era of human civilization, with Integral Consciousness rising at its leading edge. Our members don’t use Integral Life as just another media subscription they use weekly or discard. Instead, most stay with us for years, using Integral Life to learn Integral Philosophy and build an integral mind slowly, methodically and when they need it. We’re here to help you shape the future that’s emerging no matter where your life takes you.

Get Full Access For $1 (30 days)* Or explore all membership plans → * Trial price for the first 30 days, then $20/month. Cancel or switch plans in 2 minutes at any time.

Self-hatred is something we’ve all had to face at one time or another, particularly when we feel like we are powerless to change qualities that we don’t like about ourselves. And if we begin to confuse the parts of ourselves that are causing us pain with the whole of the self, that pain can quickly become unbearable, making it easy to feel trapped or claustrophobic in our own skin as we fall through a downward spiral of self-loathing, self-abuse, and for some, self-annihilation.

How can we prevent ourselves from slipping down that downward spiral and succumbing to these incredibly powerful and often destructive feelings of self-hatred? How can we actually use that self-hatred as a leverage point for our own ongoing development and transformation?

I myself have begun to relate to the transformative potential of self-hatred as something like a “path of Thanatos”, where pain traces a path leading out of the darkness, and where these self-destructive emergencies can actually clear a path for new kinds of emergence, opening us up to a greater source of empathy, clarity, and self-love.

In this discussion, Dr. Keith and I explore how these feelings of self-hatred and self-loathing, when combined with compassionate self-awareness and the natural resilience of Witness consciousness, can help us overcome our resistance to change and put us back on the path of increasing wholeness, happiness, and self-acceptance. It’s an incredibly powerful discussion that we hope will help you better navigate some of these darkest corners of your own psyche.

—Corey deVos

Self-attack as a tricky defense against change

by Dr. Keith Witt

Self-attack is a common defense against change. Someone disgusted with a mistake or moral failing might feel intense anger or shame and lash inwards, as in “I’m such an idiot!” When this reaction doesn’t lead to compassionate self-observation and self-correction, it often means the person is avoiding authentic self-awareness and growth.

Interior insult can feel like a problem is being addressed but doesn’t involve true responsibility and positive change. It is a form of pseudo insight. This is so common that most of us do it at least occationally. Some of us do most of the time, which is a major block to growth and intimacy.

Is self-hatred a spandrel?

I think the self-hatred response is a natural concomitant of human moral evolution, but what use is it? How could the self-hatred defense be useful? Is it a spandrel? A spandrel is a genetic term. It is an inadvertent capacity arriving randomly with another genetic system. Is the self-hatred response a random capacity that came with morality, or aggression, or dominance? I don’t think so. I think self-hatred is adaptive, since it so often leads to attention to what needs to be healed and grown.

All humans seem to simultaneously crave change and growth while resisting change and growth to some extent. Like many human motivation systems, we have opposing drive systems to self-support and self-attack to balance each other. We crave new perspectives/behaviors while resisting letting go of old perspectives/behaviors. This is analogous to we want to go to the party, but also want to stay home and avoid being social.

This opposing-motivation-system dynamic often happens when we make mistakes or violate values. When we believe we’ve violated a value or made a mistake, our unconscious often reacts with shame emotions to motivate us to feel virtuous again, using any combinations of a variety of responses, some healthy and some not so healthy.

Some healthy responses to violating a value or making a mistake and feeling distress are:

– Look for what we did wrong, and then change thought and behavior to do right. For example, you’re driving across the desert, look at your speedometer, and see you’re going 95 MPH. You feel a little alarm at breaking the speed limit, reduce to 75 MPH, and feel better.

– Look for what you did wrong, discover an outmoded value and refine your value. For example, you’re at nude beach, suddenly feel embarrassed when you see one of your friends walk up to you naked. You remember that you’ve decided your don’t-be-nude-in-public value doesn’t apply to nude beaches, and you feel better. You’re refining your don’t-be-naked-in-public value to don’t-be-naked-in-public-unless-you’re-at-a-nude-beach.

– Mistakes can lead to self-hatred. A healthy response to a mistake is to acknowledge the initial surge of embarrassment and anger turning into a self-hatred story, and then do something different. For instance, you’re in a hurry and accidentally shatter a bottle of olive oil on the kitchen floor. You feel the surge of anger, and then relax and accept what happened. As you’re cleaning up the mess, you practice the Navy Seal mantra, “Slow is smooth and smooth is fast,” to create a new virtuous habit.

– You notice shame and self-attack, are confused about why you feel bad, and go talk to someone you trust to figure out what’s happening and what you should do about it. For example, you get uncomfortable when your friends compliment your paintings, you talk to a therapist and determine you learned as a child to not delight in your accomplishments (because parents/culture believed such delight is selfish, egocentric, unkind, etc.), and you refine your values to include the idea that it is good for everyone involved for you to feel pleasure in compliments.

Some unhealthy responses to violating a value or making a mistake and feeling distress are:

– Denying you did anything wrong, rationalizing that what you did was fine, blaming someone else for the violation—basically the whole gamut of psychological defenses used to relieve distress while not taking responsibility for what you experience or do.

– Try to coerce others to validate that you didn’t make any mistakes or have any responsibility for any problem.

– Attack yourself globally (“I’m such an idiot!” “I hate myself!” “I deserve punishment!”) to avoid specifically examining and acting productively in the incident.

This last unhealthy response—attack yourself globally to avoid specifically examining yourself in the incident—is tricky because it feels like taking responsibility by putting yourself down, but you are actually avoiding authentic change.

The dialectic of progress: child-centered parenting is particularly vulnerable to the I-hate-myself defense.

I believe that modern science-based parenting is generally superior to previous models in most ways. Persuasive social research has taught us to emphasize supporting the interior experience of each unique child while using emotional coaching techniques in an authoritative parenting environment (as opposed to an authoritarian, permissive, or unengaged environment). Unfortunately, this focus-on-the-child-feeling-heard-and-safe approach leaves children vulnerable to learning that, “I hate myself!” can mobilize support, validation, and avoidance of whatever cued the response (usually a mistake or transgression). This is like the “You hate me! You don’t love me!” defense, which can level modern parents and distract them away from providing appropriate boundaries.

Fast forward a child who can avoid responsibility with “I hate myself” and we have adults who, when confronted with mistakes/transgressions, unconsciously go to “I hate myself!” to avoid real growth and responsibility. We all make mistakes. We all hurt others on occasion. We all are regularly faced with ways we can improve through mistakes and lack of embodied knowledge. Especially in intimate relationships, the “I hate myself!” defense plunges couples into victim/persecutor/rescuer drama triangles rather than into healthy self-observation, self-correction, problem solving, and enhanced intimacy.

The self-attack defense in action

Anything that impairs compassionate self-observation and self-correction constitutes avoidance of responsibility and agency. You go to the dinner party, drink too much, and dominate the conversation. Your wife points this out to you on the way home and you get lost in a wave of self-loathing. “I hate that I do that! I’m such an idiot!” “I have no social skills!” But is there a resolve to drink less and socially reference more at the next party? If not, you’re probably enacting the “I hate myself!” defense. In extreme cases people can scream at themselves, hurt themselves, and generally attack their worth as human beings. None of these responses helps compassionate self-observation and healthy self-correction.

To further confuse situations, people occasionally acknowledge a bad habit, but not take the next behavioral self-corrective step—as in an impotent, “I really should share the floor more in conversations,” followed by the same lack of self-awareness and bad behavior at the next dinner party. This reflects the Chinese proverb, “Knowledge without action is like no knowledge.”

Time-specific and behavior-specific change is hard to fake

Mediation as alternative problem solving has been increasing in popularity since Anatol Rapoport developed the model in the 50s. Mediators report 80% positive outcomes for their process, and I believe that the satisfying results come largely from their insistence on specific focus, mutual understanding, and time-specific and behavior-specific observable change.

When working with couples, I frequently observe them complaining about each other or themselves, with a subtext of assigning blame rather than solving problems. For example, he points out that she screamed at him for getting the wrong kind of bread, and she responds, “I can be such a bitch sometimes! I hate that about myself!” This completely avoids the real issue of her attacking him when her subjective distress rises above a certain threshold. She’s unconsciously employing the self-attack defense to avoid responsibility and self-correction. A healthier response might be, “I get triggered by you making a minor mistake, I get a surge of anger, and I want to blame and attack you or me. I need to notice that surge and correct away from attacking either of us. Please point out the next time I’m disproportionate like that.” This is compassionate self-awareness plus commitment to specific behavior change (not to mention an invitation to deeper interdependence and intimacy).

Healthy self-awareness and self-correction need to be compassionate and non-objectifying

Self-awareness plus self-correction is not always healthy. Almost any awareness that privileges objectification and attack is by definition unhealthy, and there are examples with all worldviews.

– In red egocentricism, awareness of lack of fealty to the Power-God and correction towards blind loyalty degrades a sense of a virtuous autonomous self and normalizes emotional/physical violence.

– In amber conformity, feeling sympathy for the dangerous non-believers can cause guilt or embarrassment at not hating the designated enemy. This can lead to self-correction towards further objectification and abuse. Mass formation psychosis is the most deadly example of this.

– In orange rationalism, feeling ashamed of having sympathy for the loser in a business deal or sporting event can lead to dissociation and deeper resolve to be “tougher”—to objectify and exploit others more easily. This is classic extractive capitalism.

Compassionate self-observation requires a Wise Self (the Witness) and a capacity to practice humility—the acceptance of potential wrongness—and a true sense of responsibility. This naturally leads to commitments to act on personal mistakes or moral failures, resulting in both horizontal and vertical health.

We see this Wise-Self-plus-humility dynamic addressed in multiple intra-psychic therapy systems from the psychoanalytic models of Freud and Jung, to the humanistic approaches of Gestalt Therapy, Transactional Analysis, and Psychosynthesis, to the more modern systems of Imago, Dialectical Behavior Therapy, Emotionally Focused Therapy, and Internal Family Systems. All are based on compassionate self-observation coupled with specific positive behavior change.

Self-attack blocks Wise-Self-plus-humility, all the while disguised as taking responsibility for mistakes or moral failures.


Previous Episodes of Witt & Wisdom

CANCELLED: The Battle for Free Speech in the Integral Age

CANCELLED: The Battle for Free Speech in the Integral Age

Keith Witt and Corey delve into the complex and contentious issue of cancel culture, examining its implications for free speech, academic freedom, and social cohesion. They explore why understanding the nuances of cancel culture is crucial in today's polarized environment, and how an Integral perspective can provide a more comprehensive view that embraces complexity, encourages growth, and seeks balance.
The Psychology of Splitting

The Psychology of Splitting

Watch as Dr. Keith and Corey explore the psychological process of splitting, revealing how awareness and regulation of these processes can lead to a more health and healing, as well as to a more integrated and resilient self. By acknowledging the nuanced nature of our emotional responses and learning to navigate them with compassion and mindfulness, we open the door to deeper self-understanding and more harmonious relationships with others.
From the Cambrian Explosion to the Human Explosion

From the Cambrian Explosion to the Human Explosion

Dr. Keith and Corey explore the parallels and differences between the Cambrian explosion and the rapid evolution of human consciousness, discussing the profound impacts of technological and cultural advancements on our collective development.
Why Greater Depth Means Greater Responsibility

Why Greater Depth Means Greater Responsibility

Watch as Dr. Keith Witt and Corey deVos delve into the profound interdependence between human development and responsibility, exploring how our deepening self-awareness shapes our relationships and societal roles in an ever-evolving world. At the heart of the discussion is the compelling notion that as we evolve in our understanding and self-awareness, we bear a greater onus to guide, uplift, and positively influence those around us. This responsibility is especially important in the realm of relationships, where the path to trust and understanding is often fraught with challenges, yet rich with opportunities for growth.
Integral Perspectives on Alcoholism

Integral Perspectives on Alcoholism

Alcohol addiction is a deeply entrenched issue that affects a significant portion of the population, with around 10% of children being raised in a family with at least one alcoholic parent as of 2019. In this episode of Witt and Wisdom, Dr. Keith Witt and Corey deVos undertake a comprehensive exploration of alcohol addiction, its effects, and the recovery process through the lens of Ken Wilber's integral theory, which encompasses all four quadrants - individual (internal and external) and collective (internal and external).
Toward an Integral Meta-Psychotherapy

Toward an Integral Meta-Psychotherapy

Imagine a therapy where everything is interconnected, where every moment is a golden opportunity, and where the journey is as transformative as the destination. Whether you're a therapist, a seeker, or just curious about the intricacies of the human psyche, this episode promises a journey of discovery, connection, and evolution.
The Art and Science of the Intentional Love Affair

The Art and Science of the Intentional Love Affair

Dr. Keith Witt and Corey deVos delve into the intricacies of intimate relationships, exploring the concept of "intentional love affairs" and how they can be cultivated to deepen connection and intimacy. They discuss the importance of fostering better friendships, nurturing love affairs, and developing the ability to solve problems so effortlessly that they may not even appear as conflicts to others.
When Therapists Go Woke

When Therapists Go Woke

Dr. Keith and Corey examine a troubling new trend in psychotherapy, where woke ideologies are being imposed in the therapist’s office and interfering with client-based approaches to mental health. Prompted by Lisa Davis's insightful article "How Therapists Became Social Justice Warriors" in The Free Press, Keith and Corey delve into the evolving role of therapists in the current sociopolitical climate.
Mastery, Collaboration, and Finding Your Unique Healing Style

Mastery, Collaboration, and Finding Your Unique Healing Style

Dr. Keith Witt and Corey deVos explore the multifaceted nature of integral psychotherapy, emphasizing the importance of therapists finding their own healing style and the role of personal cosmologies in shaping therapeutic practice. They delve into the complexities of blending different integral systems, highlighting potential blind spots in integral cosmology and the challenges of extending beyond one's mastery. The conversation also touches on the impact of generational events and the internet on mental health and societal norms.
What Makes Us Happy? Growing Toward Anti-Fragility

What Makes Us Happy? Growing Toward Anti-Fragility

Join Keith and Corey in this enriching dialogue, as they bring forth an integral perspective on the pressing issue of mental health and resilience among youth, and explore the transformative potential of anti-fragility and the happiness strategies that can empower us to create a brighter future for ourselves and the generations to come.
How Attachment Theory Can Improve Your Relationships

How Attachment Theory Can Improve Your Relationships

As Dr. Keith often reminds us, “Everything is relationships.” And the earliest relationships we form in our lives often set the tone and cadence for all the other relationships we will ever form in our lives. The coping strategies we learn in preadolescence become our inner compass later in life, and our efforts as grownups can often be seen as expressions, compensations, or substitute gratifications for the sense of security we may or may not have felt as children.
Escaping the Comfort Zone: Motivation, Shame, and the Will to Transform

Escaping the Comfort Zone: Motivation, Shame, and the Will to Transform

Dr. Keith and Corey explore the complex psychology of motivation — the various sticks and carrots we use to get out of bed in the morning and keep ourselves moving forward in our lives, sustaining the inertia we need to push us through any number of hardships, setbacks, and growth opportunities.
Psychedelic Therapy and the Politics of Consciousness

Psychedelic Therapy and the Politics of Consciousness

In the recent 2022 midterm elections, Colorado joined the state of Oregon in its decriminalization of psychedelic substances for therapeutic use. Here Dr. Keith and Corey explore some of the major implications of this profound legal shift, both in terms of our overall emotional, psychological, and spiritual health, as well as our rapidly evolving “politics of consciousness” — those states of consciousness that are sanctioned by the state, versus those that are not.
How Change Works: Supporting Vertical Development

How Change Works: Supporting Vertical Development

Dr. Keith and Corey explore some critical strategies to help support ongoing growth to increasing wholeness in ourselves and in other people: finding a psycho-spiritual framework to help organize our knowledge, experiences, and practices (e.g. Integral metatheory), engaging in change work (psychotherapy, coaching, consulting, etc.), and seeking communities of people who we recognize as more developed than ourselves.
How Healthy Relationships Manage Conflict

How Healthy Relationships Manage Conflict

Dr. Keith and Corey discuss "post-issue relationships" — relationships where both partners have the awareness and skill to stay connected in warmth and acceptance all the time, where challenges such as irritation, anxiety, doubt, guilt, and frustration can be transmuted into problem solving and warm feelings towards each other.
Personality as the Base Note of Change Work

Personality as the Base Note of Change Work

Watch as Dr. Keith offers a "Psychotherapy Masterclass" that helps us work with various personality types as a foundation for healing, change, and self-actualization. While intended for other psychotherapy professionals, this discussion offers valuable insight for all of us, and can be immediately applied to our personal transformational work, whatever that may be.
Making Sense of Madness: Personality Disorders and Mass Formation Delusions

Making Sense of Madness: Personality Disorders and Mass Formation Delusions

Dr. Keith and Corey explore an Integral understanding of personality disorders, and how they fit into the mass formation distortions that currently seem to be happening all around us in our culture.
Authoring Your Life Story: The Hero’s Journey and You

Authoring Your Life Story: The Hero’s Journey and You

Watch as Dr. Keith and Corey take a deep dive into the human superpower of self-authorship, and how we can use that superpower to construct a more resilient, more forgiving, and more integrated sense of “self”.
How to Teach Kids About Sex and Gender

How to Teach Kids About Sex and Gender

What exactly are “developmentally appropriate, age-appropriate” ways to teach kids about sex, gender, and identity, not only for kids in kindergarten through third grade, but throughout the rest of childhood and adolescence? Which aspects are more appropriate to teach at home, and which are appropriate to teach at school? Watch as Dr. Keith and Corey share their thoughts.
An Integral Understanding of Narcissism and Gaslighting

An Integral Understanding of Narcissism and Gaslighting

In this episode, Dr. Keith and Corey take a careful look at the strategies and intended results of gaslighting (the effort to make you question your very sanity by convincing you that your memories and perception of reality are somehow incorrect, inconsistent, or unreliable) in our personal and professional relationships, as well as in media, marketing, politics, and society at-large. How can we can better inoculate ourselves from this pernicious form of psychological manipulation? Watch to find out!
The Awakened Brain: The Neurobiology of Spiritual Experience

The Awakened Brain: The Neurobiology of Spiritual Experience

Dr. Keith takes a close look at the physiology of spiritual experience. What parts of the brain are being activated when we are having one of these powerful state experiences, and what does this tell us about the critical intersection between growth (both biological and psychological development) and awakening?
Dr. Keith Witt

About Keith Witt

Dr. Keith Witt is a Licensed Psychologist, teacher, and author who has lived and worked in Santa Barbara, CA. for over forty years. Dr. Witt is also the founder of The School of Love.

Corey deVos

About Corey deVos

Corey W. deVos is editor and producer of Integral Life. He has worked for Integral Institute/Integal Life since Spring of 2003, and has been a student of integral theory and practice since 1996. Corey is also a professional woodworker, and many of his artworks can be found in his VisionLogix art gallery.